DISBARRED!

 Finally …

BAR v. GARDINER

Justice trumps politics – The Supreme Court has the final word, sending a message of hope to the beleaguered 17th Circuit.  Pray it isn’t lost on all those who aided and abetted her vile ways, or ignored their oaths by turning a blind eye as she made a mockery of all that’s good and decent in the criminal justice system …

Room Full of Mirrors
   -Jimi Hendrix

I used to live in a room full of mirrors,
All I could see was me,
Well I take my spirit and I crash my mirrors,
Now the whole world is here for me to see,
I said the whole world is here for me to see,
Now I’m searchin’ for my love to be,
Hey!!

Broken glass was all in my brain,
Cuttin’ screamin’ crying in my head,
Broken glass was all in my brain,
It used to fall on my dreams and cut me in my bed,
It used to fall on my dreams and cut me in my bed,
I said makin’ love was strange in my bed,
Yeah yeah yeah yeah yeah yeah yeah yeah yeah yeah!!

Coming Soon Rosenthal, Rosenthal, Rosenthal; SHOOT THE MESSENGER!

JAABLOG Hypotheticals  (2008)

Bob Norman – Gardiner disbarred for lying about relationship with prosecutor

SS: Gardiner disbarred

Rumpole on the Rogues Gallery

BBeat: Judges Meeting On Scandal Accomplish Little

145 thoughts on “DISBARRED!”

  1. 0

    0

    Only the beginning. More chickens will be coming home to roost. Gonna be a hot summer.

  2. 0

    0

    Scheinberg was at least smart enough not lie about it. anything less than disbarment would have been a travesty for Gardiner. She has a soft landing anyway now what about her pension?

  3. 0

    0

    Bye bye Ana, Ana bye bye;
    You didn’t have, you didn’t have to lie.
    Bye bye Ana, Ana bye bye; Because of you a man almost fried
    Bye bye Ana, Ana bye bye; You did it to yourself now Ana don’t cry.

  4. 0

    0

    I bet the Supreme Court is looking down at Broward and does not like what is happening. It does not look good for the other judges who have complaints or arrests lately. I think the Supremes wanted to send a message that they are not going to tolerate judges acting anything but to a higher standard. Oh boy, it is going to be a long, hot summer and cold winter.

  5. 0

    0

    Poor girl. Now she sits back and collects 70 or 80 per annum in pension til she checks out.

  6. 0

    0

    Mazel Tov.

    Some good news for a change concerning the cover up courthouse of the century.

  7. 0

    0

    This is a good example of pigs get fat and hogs get slaughtered.
    Boggie and the Queen B should have taken the two years that Sheinberg got. Even though her conduct was more duplicious. No they had to go in like the big dogs and use the politico. Don’t ever let the Supremes decide your fate. These guys are demagouds and will stick it up you ass.

    So Miss Anna banana you sucked as a judge. You never read shit and left lawyers standing around like idiots while you showed up whenever you wanted to. You inconsiderate Bitch- don’t let the door hit you in the ass on the way out.

  8. 0

    0

    The first couple of months the sex was hot. Does any body need a legal secretary? or a receptionist. Please help she can’t cook, doesn’t clean and is spending my money like Liz Taylor after a four day bender.
    PS
    All during lunch today Mike was texting.

  9. 0

    0

    All she has to do is set up a photography studio and take pictures of lonely judges and lawyers peckers and she will make a fortune. Oh yes, not to mention that big pension she will still collect HA HA HA HA HA She still will make more then most all of you loser lawyers.

  10. 0

    0

    This is like a television mini-series each week with all that is happening. They should do a reality show on the BCCH.

  11. 0

    0

    I think they should have made her pay for the retrial. If there is anything left in the pension coffers after restitution she can go to the movies with it.

  12. 0

    0

    So she gets a big ass pension and can work a sideline while the rest of us continues to pray a new client calls that can pay us. Who’s the stupid one?

  13. 0

    0

    How sad that she gave no thought as to how this would embarrass her family. People need to think how their actions are going to hurt their family and friends. How proud she must be to look them in the eye. Was it worth it?

  14. 0

    0

    What a sad day for broward county, it is getting really embarrassing around here to be a lawyer. maybe the sun sentinel, herald and others will start to end this charade of endorsing incumbents and giving them the upper hand and take a real look at who they are about to tell the unknowledgeable voters who to choose.

  15. 0

    0

    For someone who had everything she now has nothing due to her own actions of not being able to control herself with emotions. she should be depressed.

  16. 0

    0

    What is the Sun Sentinel going to do when some of the candidates are conducting themselves like fools also? Look at the 2012 sex scandal, that was not an incumbent. The people of Broward should start acting like they have some class. This county is becoming a big joke around Florida. I don’t think any one is getting it at home any more.

  17. 0

    0

    Gardiner disbarred today. Pollock, Imperato, Rosenthal and their pending dui s
    this is nothing new. Broward’s judiciary has been for a long time and will continue to be the laughing stock of the State.
    Joyce Julian, Larry Korda, Larry Seidlin, June Johnson, Luzzo, Diaz, Levenson, Greene, Ross Sr and on and on
    And it’s not going to change. Sad, very sad.

  18. 0

    0

    So Ana Banana gets hers at last. It’s been a long time coming. The only boob left to slip on the banana peal is Bogie. Didn’t take her long to move on down the pike. From boy toys to geriatrics? What’s up with that?
    She sure screwed up. Just another Broward judge who couldn’t keep it together. There seem to be allot of them.
    They gambled everything and lost.
    Whatever happened to Peter Potato Head?

  19. 0

    0

    Finally they do something right. Once in a lifetime they throw a lying piece of junk bimbo male or female to the dogs. My next guess is divorce court.

  20. 0

    0

    I’d move out of town too and disappear! How many times do I read the word “dishonesty” in this?

  21. 0

    0

    Here is one David did’t win. He must be so proud of (t)his wife, Ana Gardiner-Bogenschutz. I can only imagine how little Katie feels about her step-mommie.

  22. 0

    0

    Gardiner was bound to get whacked hard. Now she can devote all her time to real public service. She can bag paper cups up and down the street. Sorry, but she deserves it. All the time she used to trade winks with every new S.A. intern in court used to make me sick. And she always thought she would get away with it. Guess she was wrong.

  23. 0

    0

    If you ask me, Gardiner got just what she deserved. Like many other Broward County judges, she used the system to suit herself without regard to others. Now she pays the price for her actions. A few other Broward judges need to learn her lesson. This place has the worst judges of anyplace I’ve ever experienced. I’ve worked in 5 states over 24 years.

  24. 0

    0

    “I’ve always depended on the kindness of strangers”
    ~Ana.
    And it doesn’t get any stranger than this one.

  25. 0

    0

    A fairly watered-down version of the events in question re-Gardiner. They seem to forget four other people witnessed the rather clandestine meeting between Gardiner and Scheinberg laughing about the victim being decapitated.
    Her dishonestly regarding her emotional relationship with Scheinberg expressed to the JQC shows the lengths that some Broward County judges will go to to save their own asses.
    It represents the moral void of many Broward judges.
    Another example of this has been expressed yet again in Judge Rosenthal’s recent fiasco regarding the attempt to suppress her mug shot and the medication listed on her personal property receipt.
    Broward judges don’t seem to understand their role yet. There is apparently a long road ahead until this happens.
    Broward County judges seem to lack a sense of personal responsibility.
    Chief Judge Weinstein has done next to nothing to dispel this kind of behavior.
    Yes, Broward County judges have a very long way to go to correct their sense of entitlement.
    They are here to serve the citizens of Broward, not themselves.

  26. 0

    0

    FLORIDA U KNOW THIS COURT – IS INCOMPETENT INEPT & CORRUPT! – FUKTHISCOURT.COM

    JUDGE DAVID CROW’S STATEMENT REGARDING ANA GARDINER IS JUST SICKENING

    “[Gardiner] has already lost her judicial position, suffered public humiliation, and shows genuine remorse,” he wrote. “[Her actions] appear to be an aberration at the time of emotional and personal turmoil and should not end an otherwise distinguished career.”

    JUDGE DAVID CROW – DO YOU THINK PEOPLE REALLY DON’T KNOW?
    YOU ARE A TURD

    JUDGE DAVID CROW’S RECOMMENDATION HAS FURTHER EMBOLDEN “KAOS” IN THE 17TH JUDICIAL CIRCUIT COURT OF BROWARD COUNTY FLORIDA AS WELL AS THE STATE OF FLORIDA

    FLORIDA HAS A RIGHT TO KNOW
    THE PUBLIC DESERVES BETTER FROM IT’S JUDGES AND PUBLIC SERVANTS

    ONE CAN ONLY HOPE THAT THE FLORIDA SUPREME COURT WILL EXERCISE BETTER JUDGEMENT THAN YOU JUDGE DAVID CROW

    THE CONFLICTS OF INTEREST IN THE COURT NEED TO END!

    OFFICERS OF THE COURT DO NOT HAVE A LICENSE TO STEAL, LIE, CONCEAL AND OR DENY THEIR RELATIONSHIPS WHICH UNDERMINES AND VIOLATES THE FUNDAMENTAL TENETS OF OUR SOCIETY “DUE PROCESS OF LAW”

    “ACTING” JUDGE DALE ROSS WHOSE NAME IS NOT RECOGNIZED BY THE FLORIDA BAR AND USES SEVERAL NAMES, HIS ATTORNEY MICHAEL G AHEARN ESQ, JOHN P “JACK” SEILER, TAMARA RIMES ESQ, JUDGE CHARLIE GREENE, JUDGE MEL GROSSMAN, JUDGE MARK SPEISER, CHIEF JUDGE PETER WEINSTEIN, FORMER CHIEF JUDGE VICTOR TOBIN, FORMER JUDGE JAY SPECHLER, JUDGE MARC GOLD, CLERK OF COURT HOWARD C FORMAN AS WELL AS OTHERS ALL KNEW OF THE CONFLICTS OF INTEREST AS THEY RAPED ME OF MY RIGHTS TO “DUE PROCESS OF LAW”




    http://www.michaelgahearn.com/
    http://www.judgedaleross.com/
    http://WWW.MICHAELGAHEARNESQ.COM
    http://WWW.17THJUDICIALCIRCUITCOURT.COM
    http://WWW.SOUTHFLORIDAARBITRATIONS.COM
    ON ANOTHER NOTE
    LAUREN BOOK OF LAUREN’S KIDS SHAME ON YOU! SHOULD YOU ACCEPT ANY AWARD FROM THESE AGENTS OF TERROR AND JUDICIAL ABUSE

    http://www.flickr.com/photos/fukthiscourt_/8246136438/in/photostream/lightbox/



    FUKTHISCOURT.COM
    PART OF THE “FUK” (FLORIDA U KNOW) NETWORK OF SITES

  27. 1

    0

    Ok, ok ok, so let me get this straight on one side you have a narcissist judge with a face like a potato flirting with her ASA’s who of course think that’s gonna get them higher on the food chain. She gets caught during a murder trial and the ruling parties that be finally shut her down cause who knows how many times in how many trials with how many ASA’s this happened etc..etc.. On the other side her stupid I mean super lawyer who thinks he can get her off with a slap end up marrying her ?? ..bleech ..R u kidding me ?? And now others arrested. What’s in the water down there.

  28. 0

    0

    Bye bye Ana. Could not happen to a more deserving person. Disbarment is meaningless without the restitution. She and her former lover Howard the humble should be stripped of their pensions and be forced to pay for the cost od the retrial. Not just tender and rosenbaums fee but also all the time spent by staff witnesses juries etc. Good riddance to you Ana hope you’re life is as miserable as you made it for others. Too bad the powers that be could not send you to prison. Look at the bright side now you have a reason not to work

  29. 0

    0

    schadenfreude:
    The reason the bells are ringing within the village is that witch has been defeated and the broom brought to the wizard.
    Ana’s bizarre relationship with Jenne made her feel she had dominion over the entire sheriff’s office as well.Her will was everyone’s pain. Karma is a bitch only if you are. The two that thought they would rule together got what that earned; Jenne-jail and suspension, Gardiner-disbarment. Karma has enacted her will……

  30. 0

    0

    So which or witch division is the divorce going to. If you get real lucky it’s Renee and her broomstick is broken.

  31. 0

    0

    almost 1000 calls and 500 texts is not a friendship anymore than 1 ambien is a wrecked patrol car…i have some pretty close friends but I don’t contact them 1500 times unless I’m looking for some.

  32. 0

    0

    She lied. She and her lawyer now husband played the game and lost just adding to hubby’s long and growing list of losers.
    She attempted to destroy everyone in her path including a law student who blew the whistle on her and her prosecutor boy luv and then attempted to pull down the rest with her (Judge Charles Kaplan, now deceased) and then got every fellow slime bag in Broward to testify to try to save her even after Backman failed miserably to save her from the JQC investigation with his slime trail traced to every aspect of this drama.

    Remember the pics of her crying to gain sympathy?

    Just how rotten can it get?

    Then she dumps all the little gimps she’d been hanging with and marries her lawyer.
    You gotta hand it to her. She sets a new precedent even for Broward.

    If it’s not judges falling down drunk or drugged or showing up to court drunk as a skunk, it’s blaming their drunken woes on an Ambien overdose and then thinking they remain untouchable and above answering to the public who put them there and who just pay for the pleasure of watching them falling down on TV and putting citizens in the hospital because they are so out of it.

    Yup, Broward has some kind of judges as we’ve seen and even a bigger boob at the helm named Chief Judge Weinstein.

    Gardiner got what she deserved in spades ater attempting to deceive everybody as often as she could.
    It just caught up with her.

    Hope her new hubby knows what he’s in for. He may not be so smart after all.

    Just as long as she does it somewhere else and it has nothing to do with sitting in judgment of others or practicing law.

    She burned it all down because she was so arrogant and couldn’t bring herself to tell the truth. She always thought of herself as above it all.
    Sort of like her friend in grime Backman who still has his snout in the pie.

    Sad story from a bunch of very sad people who if they ever had any character traded it in for power and a paycheck a long time ago.

  33. 0

    0

    Bet if you gave her a chance she’d do it all over again.. they can’t help themselves except to help themselves to the pockets of tax payers who pay for it all. Deplorable.
    As far as Weinstein’s explanation and tag words “Trust us” … Yeah, right. It’s been seen just what that brings along with it.

  34. 0

    0

    Leave my daddy alone!

    That bad woman stole my daddy from mommy and Emmy with her pink taco.

    Please forgive my daddy, browards greatest lawyer, his mind is clouded by Viagra, pink tacos and plantains

  35. 0

    0

    Isn’t it illegal to publish someone’s medications under HIPAA? I think they were right to redact it.

  36. 0

    0

    Why do you think Backman went into hiding after The Banana went before the JQC? Easy to figure out besides being a worm.
    He’s not that bright but you don’t have to be a genius to see where she was going and Paulie wasn’t about to get splashed with that.
    Just a matter of time and Thursday was her day.
    Congratulations on a job well done. The brilliant culmination of a brilliant career. Now disappear.

  37. 0

    0

    Seriously, Bogey, Viagra, ana’s pink taco and plantains is not a vision any of us wish to have.

  38. 0

    0

    How long does it take a Banana to turn brown? In this case, the rest of her life.

  39. 0

    0

    . I would bet LARGE, that the Motion to Suppress ‘judge” who, while being sure to make contact with the testifying officer, suggested that if the defendant was detained longer than it took to write the citation , then the evidence will be suppressed” comment, was Barbara McCarthy., true to form, ……..or a damn good impersonation. I then looked and realized she may not have yet been on the bench, but it’s more likely the most recent great Broward Courtroom subject of gossip is the delusional Ana………I mean if shes not……nobody is!! This shit is just another day, for a few less judge’s today then before but why the f*** should they exist at all!! Next Sentinel Headline: ” Broward Judge Not arrested today” Sources are reporting that there have been no new broward bench arrests since the last and recent one……..stay tuned!! Who gives a Shit? …….Nobody……….Thats Who………and that, my fellow lawyer, winers and complainers is just the way it is!! Time you ALL up and OWNED IT…..Donthcha THINK? I meam wtf are you “collectively” doing to raise the social awaremeness and give a rats ass enough to rip yourself away from “Americas Got Shit” and reality emptiness. There is nothing going on here that gives anybody ANY reason to CHANGE!! And, pardon me for SCREAMING, BUT THE LAST TIME I CHECKED, THIS KARMA GETS WORSE, UNLESS THERE IS, FOR THOSE WHO REQUIRE THE CHANGE , A DAMN GOOD REASON!!! There is NO reason…..SO ITS NOT GOING AWAY……

  40. 0

    0

    Gardiner knew what she was doing was wrong but it didn’t stop her. Now she has paid the price. Wonder how she feels about herself now?

  41. 0

    0

    Paulie should move to Costa Rica or somewhere similar, where a small BMW is a big deal.

  42. 0

    0

    Before casting stones, remember that we all live in our own glass houses. We are all fighting our own battles and many of us do so secretly. So before taking pleasure in the misfortunes of others please consider that someday it may be you. It’s called being human.

  43. 0

    0

    Tell it to all the poor young men still doing maximum sentences in prison for whatever de minimis charge because they dared to exercise a constitutional right to trial with lying cop witnesses and a dirty lying referee.

  44. 0

    0

    Being the attack dog all that’s left. No more JQC, No Judge Babyback, No Circuit Arlene, No license Ana.

  45. 0

    0

    Gardiner is just an example of one disgraceful Broward Judge whose actions ultimately ends with disbarment.

    I’ve worked in several divisions.
    I can’t feel sorry for her when I used to see her flirt with everything in pants in that division for two years.

    She was a smart lady but obviously had some real emotional hang-ups not the least of which included being man hungry to the point where her whole attitude would change instantly from pit bull to let’s get sexy.

    It was very strange. She would always treat women differently than she would men.
    I’m not surprised by her disbarment after following this for a while.
    Now they should do something about some of these other judges who have equally as bad problems if not worse.

    What’s with this place anyway. Broward has the most unprofessional judges I’ve ever seen.

  46. 0

    0

    The irony of he statement below is few if any attorneys made any money on Chinese drywall

    FROM: Jeffrey Backman Announcement – Forwarded by Barbara Effman

    Since the beginning of my campaign last April, I have been honored and humbled by the outpouring of support from the entire community, both legal and non-legal. As many may have noticed, I have recently been absent from meetings, events and other campaign opportunities; this is because of my dedication to my family and my clients. During the past year, I had my second daughter and it is true what they say…”two is much more difficult than one”! Not only has that addition changed my entire existence, but my primary responsibilities and expertise as a partner at Adorno & Yoss have evolved over this last year with the growth in volume of the complex litigation cases I have been handling, most particularly with respect to Chinese drywall. As a member of the steering committee for the federal multi-district litigation taking place in New Orleans, along with the litigation taking place throughout our state, I have been immensely involved in seeking a resolution to the issues. Great responsibility has been placed on my shoulders and my clients and partners are relying on my skill and expertise. Obviously, when I began my campaign I had no idea of the extent that I would be involved in this complex, national litigation. To abandon my clients at this point in time, with the major push to get all the cases to trial and resolution, would be, in my opinion, placing my clients in a very difficult position. I truly believe that judges should represent their constituents with honesty and integrity; to achieve those goals requires a deep and abiding commitment to do what is right for those we represent, be that the people or the clients. That commitment, the dedication to my clients, the growth of my practice, and the demands placed upon me have caused me to re-evaluate my priorities, and thus, after much thought and consideration, I have decided that withdrawing from the race to become your next Broward County Court Judge is what is in the best interests of my clients and family. I look forward to the day that I can devote the appropriate time and attention to my pursuit to become a judge; at that time, I am hopeful that you will support me just as you have during the last year. Please know that this decision was extremely difficult and I intend to return every contribution in full.‬

  47. 0

    0

    Listen Up: Whoever makes a false statement… under oath in an official proceeding that relates to a capital felony, commits a felony of second degree. There is NO statute of limitations for perjury in official
    proceeding that relates to a capital felony. ANA GARDINER NEEDS TO BE CHARGED WITH PERJURY.
    The Supremes would have done it themselves, but for separation of powers. She cost the taxpayers and citizens untold damage financially and otherwise. There was great public harm! She flat out lied under oath on several occasions.
    Maybe she’ll lose her pension as a convicted felon.
    Why is the State Attorney doing nothing? If it were you or me, we’d be prosecuted to the MAX. After that Supreme Ct. opinion, I gotta believe there is MORE than a reasonable likelihood of conviction! Maybe she’ll have to repay the cost of those trials if she’s convicted of felony… or maybe do some time. It’s time to forget the politics with Bogie and file charges.

  48. 0

    0

    Gardiner is in Europe for a month with Bogie. She should be paying restitution for the cost of the extra Loureiro trials. John Q. Citizen works hard for the tax money that funds those trials. She maybe had immunity from civil liability as a judge…. but she should have to pay restitution as a convicted perjurer.
    AND she should lose her pension. Get the State Attorney to do his job & appoint a special prosecutor.

  49. 0

    0

    Can’t think of one Broward judge who’s more deserving of this disbarment. Wish they’d clean up the rest of them. A bunch of drunks and ego maniacs.

  50. 0

    0

    It seems to me that these circumstances are exactly why there is no statute of limitations re: perjury in proceedings related to a capital case. The fallout and miscarriage of justice that occurred as the result of the
    fraud on the court needs to be redressed. NO ONE should be permitted to subvert justice in a capital case.

  51. 0

    0

    One Backman is more than enough. Can you imagine having had another one? I remember his pathetic drop-out letter. Although his reasons had nothing to do with him dropping out of the race as posed I’d bet, you can bet that Daddyback was behind Babyback’s change of mind. Like daddy, like son. Follow the snail trail. It leads back to Daddyback and it’s undoubtedly sticky.

  52. 0

    0

    WHAT EXACTLY IS CHIEF JUDGE PETER WEINSTEIN DOING WITH HIS TIME? HE HAS NO CASE LOAD. DOESN’T EVEN ADDRESS THE RASH OF OUTRAGEOUSLY BEHAVING BROWARD JUDGES UNLESS HE IS FORCED TO BY THE MEDIA. AND THEN POINTS FINGERS AT EVERYONE AND EVERYTHING ELSE THAT HAS NOTHING TO DO WITH THE MELTDOWN THAT BROWARD JUDGES SEEM TO BE SUFFERING DUE IN LARGE PART TO HIS OWN INEPTIITUDE IN DEALING WITH THIS PROBLEM IN THE FIRST PLACE.

    THERE’S NO DOUBT IN VIEW OF THE MANY BROWARD JUDGES THAT HAVE EITHER BEEN REMOVED FROM OFFICE BY THE JQC, THE FLORIDA SUPREME COURT OR THE MULTIPLE BROWARD JUDGES WHO HAVE SUBSTANCE ABUSE PROBLEMS, THAT THERE IS IN DEED A VERY BAD PROBLEM FACING BROWARD COUNTY. BUT IS CHIEF JUDGE WEINSTEIN ABLE OR WILLING TO DO ANYTHING ABOUT IT BESIDES HAVE A JUDGE’S MEETING WHERE NOTHING IS ACCOMPLISHED?

    THE PROBLEM MAY VERY WELL BE HIM.

    FACING THE FACTS OF BROWARD’S JUDICIAL PROBLEMS IS A START.

    STICKING HIS HEAD IN THE SAND TILL RETIREMENT AND PRETENDING IT WILL GO AWAY IS NO REMEDY.

  53. 0

    0

    If gardiner and bogey are on vacation at this point she is showing about as much remorse as when she was caught in the big lie to begin with. Typical broward judicial hubris.
    What is wrong with these people?
    What is wrong with the judges in Broward?

  54. 0

    0

    For once Justice wins out over politics!
    It’s a rare thing in these parts.
    These punks lord it over everybody that appears before them and then lies under oath and only caves in after they show her the 900 plus phone calls and 400 plus texts and they still thing they are above it all.
    This judge should never have been sitting as a judge in broward or anywhere else.
    At least she wasn’t a drunk or pill popping judge like the rest of them apparently in broward to look on the bright side.
    Just a big fat whopper of a deceitful hottie that thought she would get away with it until she got it caught in her own game.
    Now I supposed she collects her big fat pension and is lucky she isn’t doing a stint in jail which is where she belongs.

  55. 0

    0

    A great big F U to all the scuz at Sao that went out of the way to torture Ms Sheila Alu.

  56. 0

    0

    Their relationship must be like arroz con pollo. He’s the arroz, just a good cushion, and she’s the pollo on top. The punishment fits the crime here.

  57. 0

    0

    Broward judges pontificate truth in order to ascertain justice then don’t tell the truth themselves? Gardiner is just another one that finally has to pay the piper. She deserves her harsh sentence. She really thought she’d get away with it I guess.

  58. 0

    0

    Funny thing, I heard she was a pretty good Judge before she fell in with a certain somebody who thought he was hot Judge shite……..

  59. 0

    0

    In Paris on permanent holiday. Not bad. And with her pension intact. Not much, true. But she set it up pretty well. She’s hooked the next duffis.

  60. 0

    0

    The one with a her license lease step up. Um Ana not so fast. Mary you may have not been able to keep your man from the pink taco but you still have your bar license and the fat house in sea ranch

  61. 0

    0

    Why did scum sleaze ball Backman suddenly resign from the JQC? He has skated his entire career. I guess Karman will get him in the end.

  62. 0

    0

    No sense asking if the air is any good when it’s the only thing to breathe.
    What if angels sat on pinheads.
    This is the Broward Judiciary you’re talking about.

  63. 0

    0

    Gardiner didn’t have a chance. Didn’t Backman mentor her? Another Frankenstein in the making… Another weasel gets popped.
    Why does justice always come from outside Broward? Easy answer: Because Broward is hopelessly corrupt with the worst judges in the state.

  64. 0

    0

    It is not over–it is JUST BEGINNING. thus spracht Canon 3D looking for 1! So here’s to all you sucka** other lying and cowardly lawyers and judges who aided and abetted by act or omissions an refusal to act.

  65. 0

    0

    Gardiner just got caught, that’s all. It’s been said that Broward judges do it all the time. I mean, have romantic affairs with prosecutors and defense counsel that are trying cases before them.
    Lonely deal by the sounds of it.
    That doesn’t make it right. We all knew Gardiner was playing this game.
    First they tried to cover it up.
    She attacks a law student and attempted to do everything within her considerable power to intimidate her to quash the initial report of this violation.
    Was busy making alot of phone calls and texts along the way. Hey, it takes a plan.
    Then she thought she was covered by Paulie on the JQC in his regular form for errant Broward judges.
    That didn’t work and resulted in Paulie resigning from the JQC. That’s was a good thing. He’d been covering for Broward judges for years on the JQC.
    One thing she didn’t count on in her unbridled arrogance was that lies do catch up with you eventually.
    The crying gig was just as embarrassing to all the other judges as it was undoubtedly for her.
    Maybe Holmes mostly. But, hey, you get what you give.
    She ruins Howard Scheinberg’s chances for much of anything in the future in the process. Just another wayward boob that got caught in her widely cast net.
    Embarrasses and throughly puts another Broward judge, Judge Charles Kaplan who died of a heart attack in the following weeks, in a horrible predicament for witnessing the event that led to this. Didn’t care. Just another Broward judge. It’s his problem.
    Gets every Broward power broker, shameless charlatan and political huckster to testify on her behalf to try to save her hide.
    We’ve seen these same buffoons make utter fools of themselves before.
    Go ask her friend Jenne who she glued herself to from the beginning. It was kind of like a rehersal for her gig.
    Gets remarried in the interim. Waits for her new husband to work his magic with the Supreme Court. Big fat flop for all his efforts.
    And now pays the price for all of it by being disbarred, of course along with tax payers who will continue to foot the bill for her pension.
    So, I’m still trying to figure out what she might have learned from all of this if anything.
    My bet is nothing as she vacations in Europe. Could be wrong, but I doubt it.
    Ain’t Broward a fun place to practice law?
    At least she’s got some other Broward judges (who are still judges) to go drinking with. They like to do that apparently. Drink and drug I mean.
    That might prove to be of some consolation.
    She and Woozy Suzie can booze it up and talk about old times. Holmes won’t be seen with her.
    It might screw up her chances.
    Yeah, Gardiner’s a real piece of work.
    Can’t wait to see the sequel. Hear it’s coming soon. Rated R.

  66. 0

    0

    To “Rated R”… there’ s MORE where that came from.
    Ana hired Terry Fixel to represent her when she gave her depo in Bogey’s divorce. Ana’s part wasn’t pretty.

  67. 0

    0

    The Old Guard won’t allow anyone but an Old Guard Chief Judge because the Old Guard needs protection.

  68. 0

    0

    Suzie evidently complained that Mary’s mere presence in her courtroom, once Mary learned of Ana & David’s affair, was making her (Judge Susan Lebow) uncomfortable. Ana pressed her lover/lawyer Dave who pressed Dale Sanders to use influence to keep Mary out of the courthouse. The judicial influence wrongfully used against Mary was deplorable.

  69. 0

    0

    I heard she really liked her cocktails I am surprised anyone wanted her out of the courthouse, sounds like she would fit right in. She should run for judge.

  70. 0

    0

    I heard she really liked her cocktails I am surprised anyone wanted her out of the courthouse, sounds like she would fit right in. She should run for judge.

  71. 0

    0

    She’s smart, honest & not political. Those are rare qualifications these days. Not Bogey’s type anymore.

  72. 0

    0

    Former Judge Gardiner has gone to national news on Good Morning America this morning at 11:00.

    Actually the news coverage was not that bad but focused mainly on her dishonesty and brings national attention to judicial dysfunction in Broward County.

    Along with the most recent local news coverage concerning three judges in Broward having been arrested for DUI, two with property damage, and one with property damage with injuries concerning Judges C. Imperato, G. Pollack and L. Rosenthal, it reflects very poorly on Broward’s Judiciary.

  73. 0

    0

    Let ‘Em Go Lebow is a natural choice to be a Gardiner chum. She can forgive anything!

  74. 0

    0

    She always looks like she’s about to fall out of her chair! Not too clear anymore.

  75. 0

    0

    So Gardiner finnaly gets dumped for good. It should only happen to a few other Broward County judges.

  76. 0

    0

    Ole Ana didn’t even have the class to face the music when it came down. Fly off to Europe and pretend she’s above it all with Bubby. She deserves to never practice law again. She’s an embarrassment to all of us.

  77. 0

    0

    Backman must be shattered. He’d covered for these creeps for years. Not any more. Now I only wish he would buzz off.

  78. 0

    0

    Broward judges seem to be like fish in a barrel. Are they all corrupt? Gardiner deserves to have her law license taken away for good. The rest seems to be doing a awful lot of drinking and driving.

  79. 0

    0

    judge Matthew Destry is a ticking time bomb, very angry and very tempermatic. Broward need More from Our Judges are you Kidding me!!!! Broward is in aLot of Trouble allowing this type of behavior. He is very intimidating to His Staff

  80. 0

    0

    Say what you want but while all of you are waiting for the phone to ring with a possible client that has money, she is in Europe HA HA HA HA HA who’s the stupid one? I hope all of you can make enough this year to feed your families.

  81. 0

    0

    there are a lot of her cases that should be overturned and retried, because she sent a lot of innocent people to prison to please her friends and hurry her way up the ladder. This should be looked into seriously

  82. 0

    0

    You hit the nail on the head!! This skank has played every card in her deck and still seems to smell like a slightly stinky rose. Don’t make too much of the pension, it is 3.2% of 11 years, and she cant collect until age 62, if they don’t take it away. 40K per year is barely beer and clothes money for this one. Bogie pays the rest. And I like him too, he is in for a sh(* storm hanging out with her. Also, I witnessed first hand the play between convicted scumbag Jenne and Gardiner. It was a disgrace. They both give lawyers the bad rep that they have. Should have put them both in the same cell at the federal pen, her for perjury and him for corruption and god knows what else. I wonder how they sleep at night?

  83. 0

    0

    Gardiner has at last been kicked to the curb forever. Couldn’t happen to a sleazier Broward Judge.
    And the biggest laugh is on her new husband! Lying under oath is perjury.

  84. 0

    0

    Based on a comment, I did some digging about Gardiner and the JQC and found this: JQC Complaint: Who against and the Basis for Complaint: This is a formal Canon of Ethics Canons 1, 2, & 3 and Criminal Complaint by the following named Judges and attorneys, who, by individual & collusive, conspiratorial criminal Acts, as outlined below, abused the judicial process, procedural due process and violated the law and their duty to fairly and impartially administer the Law as written and decided, by imposing and refusing to correct an illegal/unstatutory 3-year minimum-mandatory sentence, to thereby knowingly and intentionally commit and conspire to commit felony kidnapping; felony aggravated false imprisonment; and inflicting cruel and unusual punishment to deprive Complainant, L. B., of his lawful liberty without Due Process or Equal protection of Law prohibiting it, and direct, intentional, knowing criminal Violation of Law and Torts, contrary to FS 775.087(1) (1993-94) [3-yr min.-man] enhancement “except a felony in which the use of a weapon or firearm is an essential element”]; FS 921. (1994) [36 points, mandatory non-state prison, probation only for a “first felony offender”]; FS 787.01(1)(a) 2., 3. & (2) [Kidnapping]; FS 787.02((1)(a)(2) & (3) [False Imprisonment]; FS 775.012(5) [“condemning a lawful act as criminal”]; 775.012(4); 775.021(1) & (4) in a consistent, systematic, fraudulent, collusive and conspiratorial manner and unlawfully engineering the fraudulent use of the PCA to knowingly deny lawfully requisite re-sentencing and release from unlawful custody, to knowingly commit and continue the commission of these felonies as a cover to aid and abet themselves and all others named herein, to avoid arrest, prosecution and punishment of themselves and those who initiated and continued this collusive conspiracy, contrary to the crimes themselves directly and as Principals in the First Degree [FS 777.011], and contrary and in violation of law and FS 777.03 (accessory) and FS 777.04 (conspiracy) for these crimes, and in collusion with the Broward State Atty.’s office and named ASAs who were also not going to prosecute themselves or the judges for their duplicitous crimes they solicited, invited and protected. This is particularly true of Judge Stone in collusion Complainant’s other appellate panel JJs, Gunther and Farmer, because J. Stone actually wrote the opinion of law that he was now denying due process and equal protection of to Complainant, L.B, as well as covering up for the illegal fraud of Gardiner’s denial and Carney’s original imposition of this illegal sentence. Judges in the 17th Judicial Circuit in collusion- conspiracy with Bwd ASAs and defense counsel, Case No 94-1126610A: Robert Carney, III, FBN 205435,17th Judicial Cir. Trial Judge Case No 94-11266;(in duplicity-assistance of ASA Heath Eskalyo, FBN 98102 & defense atty. G. Cunningham, FBN 302554 who assisted J. Carney in violating 775.087(1),775.087(1), vs. Rule 4-8.4(f)

  85. 0

    0

    Continued: Ana I Gardiner, FBN 735280, successor trial Judge and 3.800(a) Judge
    in duplicity with and assistance of ASA 3.800(a) prosecutor J. Scott Raft, FBN 559441 and defense PD Diane Cuddihy, FBN 434760) v. rule 4-8.4(f) ++);
    NOTE: Judge Gardiner declared on the record and in 3.800(a) denial opinion, her intentional prejudice and partiality in her ruling and on several other occasions in complainant’s post-conviction proceedings “to only do what prosecutor, Scott Raft wanted her to do,” in performance of her judicial duties. J. Dale Ross, FBN 164854, then as Chief Judge of 17th Judicial Cir Ct. in violation of his duties under Fl. R of Jud. Admin. to insure timely, fair, impartial and lawful rulings from J. Gardiner. Judges In the 4th DCA Appellate Panel Case No. 4D01-2697: Barry Stone, FBN 78567, 4th DCA 3.800(a) Appellate Panel and central engineer and architect, Gary Farmer, FBN 177611, 4th DCA 3.800(a) Appellate Panel, and Bobby Carol Gunther, FBN 94441, 4th DCA 3.800(a) Appellate Panel:
    Who ALL, knowingly and in collusion and conspiracy, fraudulently and unlawfully PCA Gardiner’s unlawful ruling and also refused and denied Benson Motion for Re-hearing & Clarification toprevent “expressing” an opinion they knew would be quashed again.
    Mark Polen, FBN 115840 as CJ of 4th DCA and co-conspirator of Stone-denying
    complainant’s Habeas Corpus (Case No. 4D01-2645) Who, Knew the facts and the law regarding Benson’s case, and all, in collusion and conspiracy, deliberately, knowingly, intentionally and illegally imposed and, then continued and conspired to continue to impose this illegal-unstatutory sentence by refusing, obstructing and denying the lawfully requisite granting of Benson’s proper re-sentencing and immediate release from unlawful custody that had already exceeded lawful limits by over 18 months, upon complainant’s motion, and intentionally breaching their judicial duties and violating, continuing to violate and conspiring to violate FS 775.087(1) and unlawfully deprive Complainant of his freedom with out Due Process and Equal Protection of Law prohibiting it and direct, intentional violation of this Law. This was deliberate and intentional Fraud Upon the Court as well as Criminal/felony Actions with their decisions, regarding the knowing unlawful, intentionally criminal conduct, conspiracy to commit it and refusal to correct it according to the legislative remedial appellate procedures and requisite results under Florida Rules of Crim. P. 3.800(a), the Florida and United States Constitutions Due Process and Equal Protection provisions, protections and mandates, and Fl. Const Art. 1. s. 21 [meaningful/unabridged/impartial] Access to the Courts and Fla’s lawful appellate processes and requisite lawful remedies, individually and in conspiracy with each other and requisite lawful remedies, individually and in collusion and conspiracy with each other and also with the listed attorneys representing the Executive Branch.

  86. 0

    0

    cont’d: who requested and assisted these judges to violate and commit these violations of the law, contrary to Conduct Rules including, but limited to: Rule 4-8.3(f) “assisting a judge” in intentionally and knowingly making fraudulent and unlawful and unconstitutional rulings “through misleading and false legal argument,” breach of fiduciary duty and continuing to accept their paychecks for this performance and acts and breach of oath and fiduciary duty, Relative to Named 17th Judicial court Case No. 94-11266CF motion 3.800(a) To Correct Illegal Sentence and 4th DCA Case No. 4D01-2697, PCA denial of Appeal of Denial of 3.800(a) to Correct Illegal Sentence and denial of Motion for Re-Hearing En Banc of Denial of Appeal to Correct Illegal Sentence by all these Judges in collusion with other Judges and the Broward State Atty.’s ASA and Palm Beach Branch of the Atty. General’s Office AAG Officer’s of the court and the State as Benson’s defense atty. Furthermore, it was done by PCA without opinion to obstruct and deliberately prevent appeal to the Fl. S. Ct. which established the case law affirming the statute that prohibited Complainant’s illegal sentence on this issue, where their decisions would not have survived review and their criminal knowing, intentional actions exposed.
    The only thing that would prevent such finding is if the JQC breached, failed and refused to do its requisite duty and dismissed this Complaint, well-founded in fact and law. Standards of Review and Statutes and Case Law That SHALL Be Applied: Canon 1. A Judge Shall Uphold the Integrity and Independence of the Judiciary; Canon 2. A Judge Shall Avoid Impropriety and the Appearance of Impropriety…Canon 3. A Judge Shall Perform the duties of Judicial Office Impartially and Diligently. And all applicable subsections of these 3 Canons are included. Complainant draws special attention to Canon 3 D. “Disciplinary Responsibilities:”(1)[JQC] Judges who [now]have received [this] information and have actual knowledge that demonstrates a “substantial likelihood” that(all)judges [in this complaint] have committed [stated] violations of this Code [as well as the criminal acts complainant described and identified] SHALL take appropriate action [including immediate removal and criminal prosecution]. (2)[JQC] Judges who [now] have received [this] information and have actual
    knowledge that a “substantial likelihood” that [all] lawyers have committed a violation of the Rules Regulating the Florida Bar SHALL take appropriate action [disbarment&criminal prosecution]. Additionally, “Fraud Upon The Court” as used and referred to in this complaint shall be construed by the following definition and standard, and as being “beyond accident, mistake or inadvertence as to show knowledge and intent” and Florida Rules of Evidence, including, but not limited to: 90.201; 90.404(2)(a)[showing motive, opportunity, intent, plan, knowledge absent mistake or accident]90.405; 90.406 [Routine PCA fraud]

  87. 0

    0

    cont’d 4: 406 [Routine practice of fraudulent use of the PCA to obstruct justice and commit felonies]; 90.608 (1),(2)&(5) (witnesses being all listed including J. Stone against himself by previous statements); 90.609 (1) & (2); 90.614; 90.706: 7 J. Moore and J. Lucas, Moore’s Federal Practice, P60.33 (2d ed. 1979)]. Moore’s states that fraud upon the court is only that species of fraud which does, or attempts to, defile the court itself or is perpetrated by officers of the court so that the judicial machinery cannot perform in its usual, impartial manner. Id. (Emphasis added.) Fraud upon the court is defined as action(s) by a member(s) of the court that is directed at the judicial machinery, itself…where a member of the court is corrupted or influenced…and has not performed their judicial function…[and] where the impartial functions of the court is corrupted. see Bulloch v. United States, 763 F.2d 1115, 1121 (10th Cir. 1985) & Kenner v. C.I.R., 387 F.2d 689 (7th Cir.1968) and clearly outside the jurisdiction and direct duty and function of the court and waives immunity and time. Fraud upon the court such that it forces the court to re-examine decisions is “that species of fraud which does or attempts to defile the court itself, or is perpetuated by officers of the court so that the judicial machinery cannot [or, as in this complaint, deliberately does not] perform in the usual manner, its impartial task of adjudicating cases.” Moore’s Federal Practice, 2d ed., p. 512, ¶60.23; Kenner v. C.I.R., 387 F.2d 689, 691 & n.11 (4th Cir. 1968). So There Is No Misunderstanding: AS Maintained In and The FOCUS of This Complaint IS: These rulings and conspiracy to protect conceal and continue them are contrary to law, undermined the judicial process. They are not mere “adverse rulings.” They are systematic “illegal,” “unstatutory” and “unconstitutional” RULUINGS, as matter of statutory law and which similar rulings have been extensively and repeatedly been upheld as “unstatutory” by the Florida Supreme Court and Un-Constitutional by the Federal Cir. & U.S. Supreme Courts and are therefore not discretionary or permissible and thereby, intentional and knowing Fraud Upon the Court.
    These unlawful and unconstitutional and fraudulent Rulings caused, resulted and were designed to result in and continue Criminal felony and tort kidnapping, Criminal felony and tort false imprisonment of this Complainant, in intentional violation of due process and Equal Protection of Law.
    Complainant is not asking the JQC to correct this illegal sentence, already completed [even though this sentence is still required to be corrected as a matter of law simply because it was against the law]. This complaint is demanding these Judges and other quasi-judicial officers of the court be punished to the full extent of the law and the Rules for their arbitrary and reckless disregard for the law in & commission of felonies by their arbitrary and reckless disregard for the law….

  88. 0

    0

    Gardiner was a disgrace from day one. Not that there aren’t still Broward judges as bad if not worse, but she deserves what she got.

  89. 0

    0

    Did some more digging. The above JQC complaint was summarily dismissed because the JQC had its Exec. Dir. determine that imposing an unstaturory- illegal sentence and subsequent refusal to correct it by Gardiner and the 4th DCA does not violate Canon 2A (A judge shall respect and comply with the law… and/or Canon 3B(2) A judge shall be faithful to the law and maintain professional competence in it, especially when petitioner’s motion clearly sets forth the law requiring correction of the illegal sentence an immediate release affirmatively made her professionally competent in the law because there was nobody–judge or lawyer competent to determine if the statute or case law was violated of ignored.
    Having attended Gardiner’s trial, Bogie presented multiple witnesses vouching for Gardiner’s exceptional knowledge of the law.
    So the question that begs, is how can any judge or lawyer certified by the Bar to practice — read, know, understand and interpret and practice the law in court, not have that same ability on the JQC?
    Apparently some of the answer lies–and I mean LIES–with 4th DCAer Barry Stone who, back in 1989 declared in Lareau, 554 So.2d 638: “It is undisputed that a defendant convicted of an aggravated [offense] by using a deadly weapon under the section [of the statute that requires use of a deadly weapon], may not be subjected to further enhancement of the penalty through application of s. 775.087(1), Fl. Stat. “because the weapon is, as defined under that subsection of the statute, “an essential element” of the offense” [and therefore excepted by statutory language]. “See also Williams v. State, 358 So.2d 187 (4th DCA 1978).” “[in Williams…This court held the same [requisite correction]for an aggravated assault in which the weapon that was the essential element was a firearm requires correction to a legal sentence…” and the S.Ct affirmed in Lareau, 573 So.2d 813 (1991) as did as Watson’s agg. assault, 591 So.2d (2d DCA 1991) stating:“[Watson] correctly argues that the trial court erred in enhancing his sentence for aggravated assault under section 775.087(1)(c), Fla. Stat. (1989)” because “that section only permits the enhancement of the sentence when the use of the firearm not an essential element of the offense charged, [citing:] Webb v. State, 410 So.2d (1s DCA), review denied, 421 So.2d 68 (Fla. 1982) and Williams v. State, 358 So.2d 187 (4th DCA 1978).” So when Stone PCA Gardiner’s denial of correction w/o opinion, thereby forcing completion of the 1994 full illegal and unconst. 3 yrs as well as prohibiting appeal, &not declaring a conflict with his very own case law was beyond any member of the JQC to determine truth because Stone exercised his “discretion” to PCA because Stone’s panel, App Rule 9.315(a) determined that even his own case law on a statute “did not demonstrate any reasonable grounds” to reverse and correct this petitioner’s illegal sentence. And that is why Stone also sat on the 2000 PCA Jud. Mgt Com

  90. 0

    0

    If this is true, and the information alleged seems specific enough to be verifiable, Gardiner should have been prosecuted by the JQC as well as criminally long before she was in this case and every case should have been reviewed. Was it? If not, why not? It would seem to confirm all the comments as well as the protections and lack of accountability repeatedly discussed regarding the disgraceful conditions of the 17th Jud Cir and the 4th DCA that cannot be trusted to have any integrity whatsoever in any other case. Once a liar, always a liar–isn’t that what prosecutors in Mr. Satz’s team claim for everybody else but themselves when they are prosecuting. Don’t they have any duty to seek the truth. Was any complaint made to the Public Corruptions unit of Satz’s office. Did Satz man-up and admit even is own staff repeatedly lied and cheated or did he do his routine cover-up reputed reputation in the community? It sound like this is outrageous but typical SOP. Where is FDLE? Where are the Feds? Does Satz own them too, like the judges?

  91. 0

    0

    Sounds like somebody better think about keeping their mouth shut before it accidently gets shut for them and they find them self being gator bait.

  92. 0

    0

    I’ll just take off for Italy and hide out until the dust settles. After that I’ll dislodge that extra weight I recently picked up along the way. Alot of people get divorced after a year or so.

  93. 0

    0

    Bill,
    Has the post from “helpfulsuggestion” been reported to law enforcement?

  94. 0

    0

    Looks like gardiner got hers. About time these broward judges find out the hard way you can’t lie under oath and get away with it forever. Italy won the soccer match. You lost your game for good.

  95. 0

    0

    Bogenschutz filed a motion for extension of time so that he can ask for rehearing or reinstatement.

Comments are closed.