ENTER McCARTHY …

In one of the worst weeks for the 17th Circuit in years, details are emerging concerning a trial with Barbara McCarthy featuring a pair of female defense attorneys.  One of the attorneys has a newborn, and requested time during the trial for a pump break.

Apparently, the attorney was told there wouldn’t be any recesses for pumping, resulting in the Defendant having to endure periods of the proceedings when one of his lawyers had to absent herself.  Depending on the full circumstances, it could be an appeal issue.

Whether or not McCarthy was aware of the dangers to Mom and supply concerns associated with interrupting the pumping schedule before denying the request for a recess is unknown at this time.  We’ll be sure to update when the picture gets clearer. (CLARIFICATION – McCarthy had no problem with the lawyer exiting the ongoing trial to accommodate pumping, but made it clear the trial would not be paused)

All in all a terrible few days for the Broward judiciary.  Bobby Diaz, Merrilee Ehrlich, and now concerns over McCarthy acting very imprudently indeed.  Morale in Criminal is at an all-time low, and with little oversight by the mainstream press, no end in sight …

Washington Post: Workplaces must give moms space to pump breast milk

Florida Bar Journal: Emerging Protections for Nursing Mothers in the Workplace

Coming Soon – Does Jack Tuter look down on the Criminal Division?; Court reporter mayhem!

Channel 7 reports Ehrlich resignation is finally official as of June 30th …

168 thoughts on “ENTER McCARTHY …”

  1. 3

    3

    The focus on the press is misguided. The only remedy is the JQC and elections. Bury them all in JQC complaints and run against all of them each time up.

  2. 7

    0

    To whoever said the press isn’t the issue, the only remedy is the jqc and elections: False. ONE day of press coverage over the ehrlich thing and she stepped down! The press needs to embarrass these jerks into stepping down. Ehrlich stepped down so quickly because she didn’t want any more press coverage. She was embarrassed that she got caught. McCarthy needs to be shamed into the same thing!! She’s a horrendous human and worse judge.

    1. 2

      0

      FYI. Judge Ehrlich announced her retirement date of June 30, 2018 more than a month ago to the Broward County Women’s Lawyer Association luncheon. Her retirement has nothing to do with this.

      1. 1

        0

        I agree. Judge Ehrlich and Women’s Lawyer Association were “always a bunch of cunts. This is not new.

    1. 3

      0

      Discharge fever makes you want to spit on the public.
      I feel sorry for anyone that has to wake up next to that each day.
      If it were me, I’d be on The D list everyday.

    1. 2

      0

      General Magistrate Barbara Beilly and Andrea Gundersen should be on the list and Vicki Plan, they are very hostile and abusive, Judge Gundersen .. the Supreme Court should put cameras in her courtroom, Barbara Beilly is a tyrant and bully and Vicki Plant.. they all act the same as Erlich

  3. 2

    0

    Tuter the flop. Don’t blame me I checked Fred. I didn’t forget who was #2 under Tobin and Weinstein. Big top.

  4. 6

    2

    Morale at a low. Good one. The whole purpose of being a Broward Judge is to destroy. Few of them could make a nickel working in a nickel factory before they did the political pension grab and started depositing a steady paycheck. The world is expected to take it and then suck up to them at some banquet later honoring their mediocrity. It’s a shell game with three empty shells. Don’t expect the head Judge to do anything. He’s the one that lets them lie and cover up the problems in exchange for votes and a bigger slice of the banquet plaque game.

  5. 7

    0

    McCarthy should not be a judge. There is no way to hide her incompetence and mean-spirited attitude anywhere in the courthouse. She is discourteous, unprofessional, and thin-skinned. Bad qualities for a judge. Bad qualities for a human being. She actually won Irish Mother of the Year for the Emerald Society a few years ago. What a joke. Jack, do something, please.

    1. 7

      0

      AN AWARD FROM THE EMERALD SOCIETY IS NOT MUCH OF AN AWARD AND RUN BY INCOMPETENT
      ASSHOLES WHO TRY TO MAKE THEMSELVES FEEL
      IMPORTANT
      THEY ARE NOT

  6. 5

    0

    Another Michael “TURD” Ahearn candidate. Turd and his other cronies downfall has only just begun. Hire TURD and this is what happens. TURD’s violator list goes on—- Robinson, McCarthy. Lynch…..waiting is the hardest part. More to come.

  7. 10

    2

    STAND UP TO JUDICIAL TYRANNY

    RUN ALL INCUMBENTS OUT OF OFFICE

    VOTE AGAINST ANY INCUMBENT

    STOP INCUMBENTS AND LAPDOG LAWYERS

    1. 3

      1

      Diaz and McCarthy had opponents last time. The lawyers assisted them. They won.
      Broward lawyers are sycophant masochists.

    2. 12

      1

      Many (most) if the judges in Broward are good. A few (too many) are awful. Your call to vote all incumbants out is foolish. Good ones should be retained. Most of the really awful or corrupt judges ran for election. (Ehrlich, Watson, Robinson, Pollack, Feren). The problem is uneducated voters picking judges in elections. Too much nepotism, husband and wife teams, children running on their parents name, and silly name game politics is responsible for browards woes.

      1. 11

        0

        It’s 50/50. Ross, Futch, Gardiner, Schapiro, O’Connor, Aleman, Destry et al — all originally appointed. The problem is a rotten to the core patronage system appointment game and low turnout August primary — a bunch of colostomy bags picking Judges. There needs to be FBI background checks of all candidates (not FDLE) and November elections to fix the problems.

            1. 4

              0

              The Crooked JNC is always the problem and never the answer. The Crooked JNC is also responsible for the majority of the husband wife teams and nepotism with all the Daddies Little Girls running around playing dress up.

              1. 11

                1

                Crooked dealings on the JNC go all the way back. They are supposed to be interim appointments when there’s a vacancy. Vote them all out first time up. That’s the answer.
                It’s why we have so many bimbos on the bench.
                Politics rule the selection process with mediocre Bimbos getting the prize. Wake up.

                BIMBOS DONT MAKE GOOD JUDGES
                DADDY’S GIRLS DONT BELONG ON THE BENCH

          1. 2

            0

            WE LIKED BEING BROWARD JUDGES
            IT WAS A PIECE OF CAKE WITH GOOD PAY AND BENEFITS ALL AT PUBLIC EXPENSE

            WE LIKED BOOZE AND DRUGS TOO

  8. 7

    0

    Erhlich has been abusive all throughout her tenure in Family. She’s rude Ill tempered plays favorites and, above all else, incompetent and defensive about it. One of the worse cases of black robe fever in years. McCarthy is such a miscreant her marriage to Birken, a gentleman, blew up in a short time. Personally, she’s a nasty mean spirited and unprofessional.

    1. 10

      0

      It’s such a shame. We’re losing Judge Porter and Judge Gates and other ones who understand the importance of their tenure and we’re left with blecch.

        1. 0

          1

          At least she’s smart enough to get out before Criminal goes down the tubes under the ineffective admin of Tuter.
          Heard there may be another resignation in the works.

    1. 4

      0

      DID RICHARDS AGREE TO USE MICHAEL G AHEARN AS HIS CAMPAIGN CONSULTANT?
      IT WOULD BE A HUGE MISTAKE IF HE DID
      ALL OF AHEARN’S PEOPLE GO DOWN IN FLAMES

      1. 10

        0

        Louis Schiff is a baboon with a baseball cap. But I heard that the Turd is going with a new strategy using scratch and sniff cards to entice the old farts.
        I’d have one tested before sniffing.

    2. 0

      0

      Yes! Let the fun begin a female will jump in that race and be waiting in wings just like richards did at soe last time
      odds anyone? one female and two males

      guess who will win?

    3. 1

      0

      Richards would be an idiot to file against anyone that hasn’t been recently appointed. There are easier pickins’ To be had. Has anyone seen him recently?

      1. 0

        0

        Coming in 2019- New powerhouse law firm with Tom Lauder of Red Broward the legal secretary.

    1. 3

      1

      Tooty is really screwing up. He needs to move aside. Jarheads are used to getting orders, not giving them. He’s failed to oversee the other judges. Put him in a division and hand it over to a more able judge to administer.

  9. 2

    10

    The only good judges in Broward are Rothschild, mchugh, Gottlieb, lynch, Rebollo, Orlando, Kollra and Porth. Everyone else is an asshat who got lucky.

      1. 5

        0

        Thanks ! I think I’m pretty wonderful too! I just love being a judge in Broward County! It’s so wonderful ! Have you read my new book ? It’s about the mentally ill.
        Call me Babs for short.

        1. 11

          0

          Lerner-Wren: “why was this signed by another judge while I was out?”

          Lawyer: “because SAO agreed the guy was in jail by mistake”

          Lerner-Wren: “being in jail by mistake is NOT an emergency!!”

    1. 17

      5

      Kollra?!? Rothschild?!? by “good” do you mean “clueless”? Let me instruct you on the law judge. I’ll try to speak slow and use simple words. Oh no, now I see the blank look of confusion. Lightweights.

    2. 14

      1

      Gottlieb? Are you kidding? A former real estate attorney who got lucky?

      He may be nice, but he’s the furthest thing from a stellar judge. Sit in his court room any day……or through a trial.

    3. 19

      1

      Rothschild = Super Lightweight = Approaching Stupid
      Lynch = Complete Moron
      Gottlieb = Practice Drying Up = Seeking State Employment

  10. 20

    0

    I’m all in for Richards v Schiff. Easy win. Kollra and Rothchild are mental lightweights. With Ahearn running Schiff’s campaign he is destined to lose big.

  11. 0

    0

    CANNOT FIGURE SCHIFF OUT…
    HE COULD HIRE ANYONE AND CHOOSES
    AN ANTISEMITIC RACISTS WHO IS CORRUPT TO THE BONE

    1. 10

      0

      Judge Richards better file in soon because Judge Phyllis is going to file against Schiff or Al Ribas. It’s. Going. To. Be. A. Long. Hot. Summer.

  12. 6

    5

    Pump on your own time. There’s nothing worse than some baby momma trying to make herself the center of attention in the middle of a trial. Get a wet nurse if baby is hungry. Or better yet, stay home and take care of your child. But don’t expect the world to stop because your brat is crying and needs to be fed.
    You bring your file to court, not your pump.
    Grow up.

    1. 6

      10

      Two milkmen looking to milk the cowto death. One does houscalls to garner your vote. The other does small appliance repair on the side. God save us from both.

    2. 0

      0

      DOES USAN HAVE A WEBSITE?

      ALL ARE AVAILABLE FOR PURCHASE!!!
      JUDGEMICHAELUSAN.COM
      MICHAELUSAN.COM
      REELECTJUDGEMICHAELUSAN.COM
      MIKEUSAN.COM
      USAN4JUDGE.COM

    1. 3

      0

      This screeching old bag needs to be made to dig the grave with her hands of the person who died before she’s committed to an old folks home herself.
      This is the best judge Broward can come up with ? She sounds like she’s mentally challenged.
      Just one reason Iwont take a case in Broward. All of their judges are crazy, drunk or high on themselves for no apparent reason but to satisfy some deep seeded urge to act out their aggressive behavior on the attorneys or public.
      This old cow needs a strap-on and a blowup doll. Better yet a blood test.

  13. 0

    0

    SOUTH FLORIDA CORRUPTION:

    YOUR CUSTOM DESIGN LIGHT FIXTURE DOES NOT WORK. YOU ARE AN UNLICENSED ELECTRICIAN.

    1. 9

      0

      No man can expect to go to heaven on a feather bed. Broward judges once again show themselves unworthy to sit in judgement of others. And Chief Judge Tuter shows he’s incapable of dealing with the atrocious behavior of judges who have forgotten they are public servants as they are so often quoted as saying.
      It’s up to voters to show their displeasure at these atrocities.
      Vote out of office all incumbent Broward judges and keep a close eye on the new ones.
      Broward has got to have the absolute worst judges in the state with arrogance and corruption endemic in their ranks with no oversight whatsoever being shown by the Chief Judge of a Circuit in chaos.

        1. 6

          0

          But Ross wouldn’t have tolerated being humiliated by Bob like Tuter did. Bob wouldn’t have done that to Dale though.

        2. 2

          0

          FROM ONE INCOMPETENT BOOB TO ANOTHER
          BROWARD JUDGES NEED LEADERSHIP
          NOT ANOTHER BUREAUCRAT FULL OF EXCUSES

        1. 0

          0

          NOBODY WANTS TO RUN AGAINST
          INCUMBENT JUDGES
          WHAT A SHAME
          ALL TALK NO ACTION

          GROW A SPINE PEOPLE!!!

          1. 24

            2

            hey kaplan. you should spend less time commenting here and go campaign. oh wait, exposure to voters would reveal your incompetence. nevermind.

          1. 28

            6

            Kaplan is a fool. Terrible attorney and with his constant ravings and meltdowns would be a disaster as a judge. Thankfully he doesn’t have
            a snowballs chance. Foolish to take on a well regarded incumbent with so many other easy targets. He didn’t do his homework and picked the wrong race. Typical kaplan baffoonery.

      1. 3

        0

        Very true, the worse of the worst , you will find them at the Broward Crthouse, sitting on these benches as if they were kings and queens. For so long they have done wrong and the chiefs of these judges have always closed their eyes. That Herlich woman had lost her mind so long ago and has always disrespected people and belittle the people. She was so unfit as a judge but yet they kept her there until this happened. Shame on you all judges and so called chief judges that allowed this to go on until someone lost her life because of her uncompassionate ways and cold heart. Your heads are even bigger than the hallways where you enter your courtrooms.

    1. 7

      0

      It doesn’t seem like there’s a lot of respect for Tuter. He’s definitely not effective.
      If Bso can vote on Israel no confidence why can’t the judiciary get rid of Judge Tuter and a get a good replacement??

      1. 0

        0

        At the minimum they owe it to all Florida Judges to make a change. It’s not fair to the responsible Circuits.

      2. 1

        2

        It is disgusting that eveyone is so quick to turn on Judge Tutor. Hide it anyway you want, the real reason for all the hate is because he is not a “family man” with a wife and kids at home. The hate has more to do with him liking to spend time with other men playing golf etc.

        1. 0

          0

          THE 17TH JUDICIAL CIRCUIT COURT
          HAS HAD IT SHARE OF BUFFOONS

          DALE ROSS (NOT RECOGNIZED BY THE FLORIDA BAR A/K/A FLABAR)
          VICTOR TOBIN
          PETER M WEINSTEIN
          JACK TUTER
          THE HISTORY OF CHIEF JUDGES IS CERTAINLY AN INDICATION OF THE FUTURE CHIEF JUDGES

          WITHOUT OVERSIGHT THE FUTURE OF THIS COURT REMAINS THE CIRCUS THAT IT IS

        2. 6

          0

          Tuter had better learn to improve his game or he’s in for a real ride with these jokers …

          WHO SAYS DADDIES LITTLE SPOOK CANT BECOME A BROWARD BIMBO JUDGE

      3. 7

        0

        Pray tell : who would be any better as Chief?
        Herding bunches of floundering attorneys turned judicial officers will present the same challenges no matter what person is in charge.

  14. 12

    0

    The Florida Supreme Court needs to get to Broward and take over the Circuit until it can be placed under either Palm Beach or Miami’s supervision. All the debauchery has been embarrassing these years but now a woman is dead. It is a sad state of affairs when a judiciary that has been a blight on all of America for so long has been allowed to remain autonomous until the ultimate tragedy has inevitably occurred. If this was a business or military operation the entire lot of them would have been out of jobs by now.

    1. 9

      0

      Yea, throw in a couple of kids to molest too. That’s their favorite. We can get then a pretty penny, and an endorsement for our election from The PBA.

      As BSO and PBSO CI’s, We’ll sell out clients in any county.

      Once in as SA, I will be able to give important positions to unethical and ignorant dead weight like my friend Allison Kelliher. We’ll make sure you’ll miss Satz dearly.

      Our Florida Bar members need access to little tikes, and of course, my administration will be geared to please Moloch. So proud to be in the child trafficking capital, and would love to be the SA.

      Thank you for your funds and support,

      Teresa Williams for States Attorney

      1. 3

        0

        Family Court Judge, With his DCF Daughter.
        Is this true? If true, is there any wonder why some attorney’s allow this behavior, and feel its normal?
        This is awful. Has any ME been done on these two?

  15. 0

    0

    South Florida Corruption:
    Unemployable electrician, theologian, private investigator, political consultant, law enforcement policy expert, uncertified court stenographer, game show host,Rabbi, Judicial scholar, advisor to Alan Morton Dershowitz, pedicure technician to 65 or older female only, car wash attendant.

    Are you running for sheriff, judge?

    1. 20

      0

      Kaplan is a loser. He should run against Fein or Haimes. Izquierdo has no fight either. He’s making a mistake with a good incumbent like Usan.

      1. 23

        0

        those are all good judges. there is way easier pickings: open seat casey, buy me a judgeship padowitz, clueless kollra, uh uh uh robinson, reversed king bailey, and alberto “ross” ribas. so many to pick from. leave the good ones alone.

  16. 1

    0

    Stop criticizing The JQC, The Elites life styles depend on our frauds and thefts thorough our rulings.

    Let’s stay the course.

    1. 7

      1

      Besides, Pedo’s are our Bread n Butter.
      Keep up the great work JQC.

  17. 0

    0

    I buy some of it.
    This qanon would agree that Robinson was impressive work.

    Pay for play is fair to the litigants.

    Therefore, SFC does not do quality work.
    Is he an attorney? No. But SFC sat in a urinal in the court house, this is his qualification. The Constitution, and The Bill of Rights mean nothing.

    That’s why all of the corruption.
    Corruption flourishes in the open.
    What SFC and many others are doing, and weathr SFC knows it fourscore and several years ago.

    I’ve been in the biz a long time.
    Never has there been more of a need for enlightenment…
    As a cert’ed professional, I can say, never before has the public been this thirsty for this type of libation. And to me, into all venues.

  18. 2

    0

    #Q #QANON – FLORIDA SHADOW GOV JUDGE KICKED OFF BENCH! – PERSECUTED TIMOTHY HOLMSETH

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.