Yesterday’s two hour JQC remedial judicial training went off without a hitch.
The meeting was mandatory for all Broward judges, and we’re told attendance was taken.
JQC staff addressed all Broward judges to gently remind them of the p’s and q’s of the judicial canons.
It is unknown whether or not the JQC tour is stopping in other jurisdictions, but we’re guessing it’s a one-off given the recent landslide of JQC cases in the 17th Circuit, already the historical all-time JQC champ statewide.
Expect happy faces on the judges at least for the time being, and be sure to post a comment right here on JAABLOG if not …
Hahaaa
Was that dickhead Coleman there? Probably sat there pissed-off the whole time, thinking he’s better than everyone.
Did Coleman bruise your overinflated ego by requiring you to answer a question
These mandatory events are always like preaching to the choir. No doubt Farmer didn’t attend. That should also be taken into consideration when the JQC evaluates any contrition. Wealthy or not, he ought to lose the pension he earned as a state legislator. The judicial job allows him to use his multiplier toward a much higher salary. The taxpayers shouldn’t have to support that moron who contributes to making even the decent Broward judges look bad.
I DODGED THAT
ETHICS ARE FOR THE COMMON FOLKS
The New Senior Partner
Hmm were the JA’s compelled to go too. Real necessary.
How embarrassing.
A few bad apples? That makes it so everyone has to get spanked. It’s silly.
It’s not “a few bad apples” Broward judges have had a problem with behavior at a much higher rate than the rest of the state. Most are good, but there are enough bad ones to ruin it. I think it is good they are all regularly reminded to be professional.
So is DCT going to allow motions to suppress be heard more easily now
What’s DTC?
Judge Debora Carpenter-Toye.
How much does her financial disclosure show? I think she can be beaten in an election if someone has the dosh.
Oh, I thought you were talking about getting a hearing.
Question
Can you request a video copy of the zoom hearing? If so what’s procedure.
I think my judge was unaffected by that conference. No second thought, totally unaffected by it. What an fing joke of a zoom proceeding today. Where do the jas and these judges come from. What law do they know and why is JA dictating or misrepresenting matters.
A JQC coming soon.
Some of you on here are really jaded.
The overwhelming majority of the Broward judges are competent, professional and let lawyers conduct their trials. And most of them are pleasant people off the bench, who engage in extracurricular community events. And they are also family people who do their best for their families, and for Broward.
But mistakes will be made by all human beings. You can’t expect anyone to be perfect, we are all human. As all of you who are reading this, and posting on here, are also human.
4 people who have had a recent issue, out of a total 90, is not indicative of any overall problem with the majority of the group, or even any overall problem with a minority of the group.
Some of you act as if any of these 4 were arrested for a crime of moral turpitude or violence.
If you’re a Judge, then the message still isn’t getting through. This’s precisely the laissez failure attitude as explains why Judges here think they can do whatever they want and continue to do just that,, ethical rules be damned.
Laissez failure attitude ?
What are you even going on about?
The post clearly states that the majority of judges are good and a few mistakes from a small number is never representative of the entire collective.
None of them have a laissez-faire attitude.
You simply want absolute perfection, and it doesn’t exist.
Don’t want perfection but come on know the law or defer your ruling.
You argue that 90 judges, who all practiced law prior to taking the bench, do not know the law.
Sure…
Yes.
Yes!
perfection doesn’t exist a lot more often here than other places 🙂
>
If CLP brought the JQC she should be commended for taking the bull by the horns.
It could be possible for the first time 17 has a CJ who puts the needs of the people of the county over those of the judiciary who think they’re somehow not in service to anyone but themselves.
Is it possible to do a story on this with the background facts?
Wrong
Is that really a Pic of Harry?
It has been a while since I saw him alive, and my memory is bad, but just not sure.
HB himself.
No, that is not a picture of Harry Gulkin, dummy. First time reading the blog?
On behalf of all BACDL Brown nose trophy seekers, I want to say we are pissed at your desecration of the legacy of Harry Gulkin.
Going around, exposing his side hobby as a filmmaker .. Sure, there’s a Wikipedia site proving it,, but, still, can’t you grant us our night of fun?
We put on a $200 per plate affair, anointing the next guy who’s paid BACDL dues the longest.
And, yes, none of us know what hot butter Harry even looked like, but ppl like Jeff Bloom need something to keep paying dues for.
LEGACY IS OVERRATED
Mistakes don’t equal serious ethical violations like impersonating the IRS or campaigning from the Bench. Don’t be so dumb.
BROWARD JUDGES
AND PROUD OF IT
Do you people watch the news? Why did we bring these people over here? They are welcome to go back. Comments?
In examining the Broward judiciary
Please rate the judges based on
Stupid
Ignorant
I have two in mind
Judicial sensitivity training has been tried before.
It didn’t work. Its like trying to teach morons math in Broward.
Who was this guy?
Who is this bald guy
The JQC should set up permanent shop here …
And DOJ!
The possibilities are endless at the 17th Judicial Circuit.
Just ask Nina Di Pietro.
Imagine the shame and scandal of being FIRED from a government job as a Public Defender for ethics and being REWARDED with a promotion to judge.
She doesn’t know the first thing about ethics.
Had a landlord tenant trial w Nina a few years back. She freaked out in her shrill voice the whole time.
I think she was pissed bc prior to her becoming a Judge, I kicked her lawyer ass over a case involving her grandpa’s commercial property in Hollywood.
Ha, Ha Nina
Her face always looks expressionless. Does she do Botox?
I don’t know what is worse: her voice or the 25 pounds of makeup on her face. Who is her makeup artist? Miss Piggy!
She snubbed Lit’l Howie. That ought to be worth something.
The word on the street is Nina Di Pietro is linked to an infamous lesbian lawyer couple at the center of an extensive criminal investigation in town. The word is the FBI is involved and records have been obtained from multiple cases.
Will someone tell us what this Leah Kraus gossip is?
I don’t really know but I know people who have worked for her and they say Krauss belongs in prison with most of her clients.
My source tells me that Leah and her wife are caught up in a public corruption scandal and in deep doo doo.
Are you implying Nina loves labia? I have my doubts.
I was called by an FBI Agent to sit for an interview at the Miramar Campus about Krauss. Has anyone else been called?
I received VERY credible information that agents from FBI and FDLE are involved in a serious matter involving Lea Krauss and her representation of a banker from JPMorgan.
The judiciary has demonstrated time and again that it cannot be trusted:
1) Most judges lack any ounce of impartiality or neutrality. For example, judges such as Coleman, Odom, Alspector, Fein, and Usan rubber stamp anything the prosecutor asks for. They ACTIVELY HELP the State. They even make arguments for the State.
2) Most judges are flat out incompetent.
3) Most judges are lazy. Them and their JAs refuse to work.
It is unacceptable. Most litigants have no faith in the impartiality, competence, or integrity of the judiciary.
Public reprimands don’t cut it. Removal from office by the JQC. That is the only remedy. Period.
Judge Odom’s JA is a disaster.
She doesn’t do shit, and when she does and fucks it up, she tries to shift the blame.
Fein is horrendous he acts nice but its all an act, he always grants what the state asks
fein is a trumper he aspirations beyond state court. Perfect time for him to leave.
I heard he pissed off the wrong lawyer and he isn’t getting past GO on a higher position.
The whole courtroom is a disaster Attitude reflects leadership
AND THE BEAT GOES ON IN THE 17TH
Levenson is so disrespectful
“I object! …and I sustain my own objection.”
– Typical Levenson
LEVENSON IS NOTHING SHORT OF A DIME STORE DICTATOR WITH A. LOW IQ
Not saying he’s a genius but he’s not dumb, he’s decently smart. His problem is two-fold:
One, he does NOT LISTEN. He anticipates arguments. And interrupts a LOT.
Two, he inserts himself into the trial or hearing.
I don’t agree. The guy is an absolute moron ! Lol
Obviously you haven’t had much interaction with him.
Levenson would have made a better garbage man than he’s ever been a judge even for a bottom rung circuit like this one !
LEVENSON AKA SUPER-PUTZ
Does anyone want to talk about black crime matters?
How about cop crimes!?!? Noone ever talks about the crimes committed by those scumbags
Broward faces the squeeze
black crimes. 1,000
Cop crimes. 1
Could the judicial system in Florida be biased and even rigged ? See The Florida Bulldog 3/15/25 : “Judicial favoritism in Miami paternity case benefits Trump advisor Jason Miller” https://www.floridabulldog.org/2025/03/judicial-favoritism-benefits-trump-advisor-jason-miller/
t
Did you see the comment from former Broward Prosecutor Sean Wydner’s Facebook on Mike Gottlieb’s Facebook?
It says “Israel is committing genocide in Gaza and needs to be stopped…one way or another. Fuck Israel.”
http://www.gentilewydnerlaw.com
Gottlieb took him to task.
I never thought Wydner was actually as stupid as he looks.
But I guess he fell for the hysteria. Most ppl in the world understand that Hamas hides underneath schools, and hospitals, etc., but there are racist idiots out there – who just dont get it
Looking for love
Did Wydner ever post F Russia for invading and killing all those Ukranians?
No. Wydner did not.
He apparently only has a thing against Jews, especially those Jews who wish to repel invading rapists.
AFTER WE’VE CRAPPED ALL OVER ISRAEL
WE’LL SEE YOU IN MIAMI BEACH
How dare Wydner criticize Israel!?!?!? He is clearly anti-semitic!
I understand criticizing Russia, China, Iran, North Korea, or even America. But criticizing Israel was crossing the line!!!!! Shame on him!
Its the very end of colonialism and thus the beginning of the decline of Israel; The clock is ticking for Netanyahu and his group of criminals; We are watching it unfold before our eyes and in the streets of Israel.
Unfortunately, the US is not far behind.
This time next year the fall of Netanyahu will occur remembered only for his multiple security failures and corrupt policies.
He’s a lot smarter than Gottlieb by far …
Gottlieb is a little girl snitch
Gottlieb doesn’t know his ass from his elbow
Israelis are the good guys and Palestinians are the bad guys. Everyone knows it, and only racists criticize Israel.
Sure, aerial images of Gaza are nasty but Israel has a right to defend itself.
Yes Israel hit some (a lot of) hospitals and apartments and markets but they posed a threat and Israel bas a right to defend itself.
It started as just another land grab. Now the piper is being paid.
Netanyahu would rather rule over a country of ashes than actually show care for either his country or its people.
Netanyahu which isn’t even his real name is Israel’s biggest disaster …
Trump, Netanyahu, bin Salman Al Saud, LLP.
Wake up dum dums.
Dearborn, Michigan voted for who?
I hope the fellas don’t screw me on my cut
We got Hormuz!
THIS IS MY HAPPY FACE
Harvey Glupskim CIA? Anyone else noticed he’s not in court when something momentous is happening on the international stage?
Where you been?
Word is that Harry HB Harvey faked his death, so as to throw off the pressure of being the preeminent lawyer / filmmaker of his time.
Glupkin reads this blog, for sure
And all those sad BACDL types chasing after his legacy ………….
Henry Glupkin hated the HB nickname. He made an honest mistake. Please. Show some respect. It was like 40 yrs ago. Put it to bed.
?
Then he’s reading it from the grave. He’s been dead for 30 years and so has his so called legacy to an organization he’d be ashamed to be associated with.
More likely to try to dodge debt collectors
WAY PASSED EXPIRATION DATE
Must be all those greasy tacos. Diaz looks like the new installment of the Walking Dead. Always kind of thought he was brain dead.
Ledee needs to learn how to talk to people without being a dick. I have never seen someone with a bigger napoleonic complex.
he doesnt need to do shit hes worth 10s of millions…go run against him and get your ass kicked.
Ive got a million or so lying around,, maybe I just throw in the measly 9k filing fee to run against arrogant Naploeanic Ledee?
You know, just for shits n giggles (and to make Ledee spend some cash)
Just more BS. He’s as leveraged out as Backman is. All the judicial gophers say they’re loaded hoping that will scare off any challengers. If they had that kind of money they wouldn’t try to hang on to a nickel and dime job as a circuit court gopher.
Sounds to me like your intimidated
Judge Ledee is one of the most polite people on the Broward Bench. It sounds like this post author is the one with a complex.
he doesnt need to do shit hes worth 10s of millions…go run against him and get your ass kicked.
He needs to spend a little of it to get a new car then ! Lol
Gottlieb is a great pick…pleas out the majority of cases, brown noses all the Judges, did nothing as BACDL president and is obnoxious to his fellow lawyers. The only thing he could do to be better qualified is be a judge. Perfect fit.
GOTTLIEB IS MY HERO
All this Gulkin Award talk makes me think ‘You either die a hero or you live long enough to become the villain.’
Not one comment on getting rid of the lazy DTU people and cleaning house on that shit bag of a unit. Shouldn’t even be in existence. A first-year law student can try a 25-year min man case where the guy was selling to a CI. It became a honey hole for prosecutors that don’t want to work.
Stop all this Glopskin crap. I’m sick of it. Bill, get control of your blog or close it down. Let’s see if he is a man or not.
Everyone is sick of Glopkin so to the point the award needs to be renamed to someone else that is relevant to the modern digital age and not forever tied and relegated to the celluloid era. For the love of G Harvey didn’t even have benefit of an Apple Newton either in court or on the set.
BACDL – A GLUMPKIN IS THE BEST WE CAN DO
Poor Israel. Long before 1948 Israel was being attacked by the Palestinians. Now the Palestinians are at it again, trying to take over Gaza and the West Bank!
Israel has a right to defend itself and expel the Palestinian invaders.
2.5 million have already left Israel with more trapped there with no way to get out now that the government has made it illegal for Israeli citizens to leave.
Its economy has tanked with more international companies and countries severing ties with a genocidal and extremist regime.
The whole world can’t be wrong.
Israel is a mere client state with a faltering government being torn apart internally by competing factions.
Its continued existence is debatable in the long run.
Since Isreal is being spoken about, what has DWS stance on the bombing of Iran. Crickets
Don’t know her stance on anything, unless it’s anti-Trump. When she may agree with his position, no comment. When she doesn’t agree with Trump she posts non stop and has the town hall meetings. Ol Debbie what happened to you the DC swamp swallowed you up. Not the UF Gator Swamp stadium.
Please come around. Ty.
Broward judges are the worst. Its going to take a lot more than remedial training to fix the problems in this Circuit. Between the lazy and incompetent judges sitting on the bench at every level, it’ll take an earthquake to dislodge them from the every day clown show that takes place in this circuit.
Poor Israel. Everyone keeps attacking them. First the Gazans. Then the Lebanese. And now the Iranians! Why can’t the palestinians and arabs just leave them in peace!
Yeah for real. Do people not see how the Iranians bombed Tel Aviv and even damaged the side of a hospital! Absolute savages. And Palestinians Arabs took over a portion of Israel’s sovereign land (Gaza/West Bank) then built fences to keep the Israelis out of their own land! It’s ridiculous!
THE PRICE OF PREEMPTIVE STRIKES
Bill: time for a new post. Anything but Glupskin.
Its time Bill stood up for poor Israel. The Palestinians are taking over their land and the Iranians were bombing Tel Aviv without provocation.
Israel has a right to defend itself.
Es ok, Israel turned Iran into its bitch.
All the hamas loving, antiAmericans can go live in NY
Iran started the war. They provoked poor Israel.
Remember kids…
“Israel has a right to defend itself.”
The world is decidedly against Israel’s policy of apartheid … If Israel is not careful, it could very well be writing its own epitaph in the long run. Millions have already fled the country and are not coming back, it’s economy is in shambles and it’s society is being torn apart by factions not likely to reach a compromise.
Repeat after me:
“Israel has a right to defend itself.”
*Israel bombs a hospital’s operating room”.
The Sheep:
“Yes Sir… Israel … has … a … right … to … defend… itself.”
I sure wish Hamas would stop hiding themselves and its weapons in hospitals.
The innocent ppl Hamas is exposing to danger.
Sure, they can try blaming Israel, but only dumb college students and racists will fall for that.
Nah that excuse is old. Maybe once. Maybe twice. But you can’t ravage a civilian population and say “womp its ok there were some militants somewhere in there”.
Only cruel and ignorant people justify Israel’s atrocities.
Any day now, right? Thats when the Hamas rapists will release all the inncocent hostages?
Could’ve spared So Many innocent lives in Gaza, but instead Hamas would rather let Gazans die, vs just giving back these poor innocent civilian hostages, lay down their arms, and agree to a lifelong brutal cruel imprisonment for their cowardly acts.
Fine. Israel will just Make It Happen!
Israel has been taking tens of thousands of hostages for decades! They call it “ administrative detention.” They torture them too, they do solitary confinement and other cruel things. All without a trial or any charges.
It was time Palestine stood up for itself!
Ha, yeah, stood up (then had their legs cut off!)
Reporter: “Mr. Hamas Rapista, will you consider coming out from underneath the human shields and fight like men?”
Hamas Rapist: “huh? This is how we show the world the kind of savages we are. We sneak over to rape innocent women and kidnap elderly ppl.”
Reporter: ” well there you have it. This is what Palestine ppl think is standing up for themselves.”
Sing the bulldozer song:
“With this bulldozer, we push them into the sea.”
So if Hamas is inside of a hospital then its ethical to bomb the hospital?
Got it!
Yep. If they rape and kill someone, then think they can go cowardly hide in a hospital for cover?
Oh yeah, Israel already tried playing that game for decades.
This time is different. Time to execute – and when you realize the majority of ppl living in Gaza (a land GIVEN to them by Israel), support Hamas, it is a “get what you voted for” scenario
You just proved to everyone that Israel and its supporters are trash.
No, it is not ethical to burn, crush, and bomb innocent people simply because Hamas is somewhere in there.
This debate is over, you’ve shown what a garbage human being you are. No point arguing with someone who supports such evil.
Israel is destroying itself faster from within than any influence being exerted on it from outside. Netanyahu and his extremist cronies are all criminals. It’s time is limited. Tens of thousands are marching against Netanyahu’s crooked government in Israel every day and the country’s resources are being bled at an alarming rate. The clock is clicking.
Israel is indeed being destroyed from within! The Palestinians took over huge chunks of Israel and built barbed wire fences to keep Israelis out.
Broward is remarkable for its unhinged judges. Their deranged behavior draws national headlines. Their incompetence is stunning.
But is Dade any better? Is Palm Beach that much better?
17 has made tremendous strides under Chief Phillips because without the vindictive vainglorious former CJ the Circuit’s in good shape.
ITS SOMETHING IN THE WATER
BROWARD JUDGES ARE DEFINITELY UNHINGED
It’s not water in the water jug it’s fing vodka with an aphrodisiac. Just couldn’t help myself.
Its too soon to give her a free pass yet. Chances are she’s as big a sell out as Tuter ever was. Time will tell whether she places her own interests over that of our Circuit.
Tuter was just an exaggerated Scherer Mole that served no purpose other than to make a fool of himself.
His Liz plan sure backfired spectacularly. The rest of his carnival act didn’t fare much better.
Why does Tuter get all the attention on this blog? Why are Gardiner and ancient judges getting attention? You all should be posting memes and pictures of all the CURRENT judges who are very very very bad and exposing their misconduct.
Let sleeping dogs lie
I CAN’T DO ANY WORSE THAN TOOTY
Broward Judges do it better. …
I had hearing regarding appellate costs. The judges order stated “ the plaintiff will withdraw the motion to tax the appellate costs and refile in the appellate case pursuant to the Florida Rule of Appellate Procedure 9.400.” The appellate court reversed and said “Pursuant to Florida Rule of Appellate Procedure 9.400(a) costs are taxed by the trial court and not the appellate court.”
I filed a motion for rehearing with cited rule and case law in trial court and a different judge, unknown why, denied the rehearing.
Do judges read the rules of procedure or case law provided. Or do they not care.
I had to appeal one lousy ruling seek review of another lousy ruling. My confidence in a fair trial is about a 1 on scale of 1-10. To put at 1-5 would diminishing my expectations.
If anyone knows who cites stuff without reading it let me know and the suite mate doesn’t read anything either.
They get paid to read, listen to arguments and make INFORMED decisions. Not unilateral decisions
How direct can the appellate court. Shouldn’t that be a JQC complaint on its face. This was not a discretionary review but a complete lack of knowledge and reading the rules
Let’s consult Glopman.
Does anyone know the real story about Galkin and the “The Low Sodium Cigarette” magazine ad campaign?
A low sodium cigarette? Huh?
Well, Harry Gulkin had a camera and crew back then, which was rare.
If someone wanted to make a commercial, and it was winter time everywhere else …then they came to Fla to use Harry, his crew n camera.
Harry was a one time, one term Broward judge who slipped off the rails and worked for scratch the rest of his career if you can call it that. His wife was his secretary. He had no involvement in the film industry nor any other entertainment sector.
Where anybody is getting this crap from is simply a figment of an overactive imagination.
The old time judges tossed him a few cases because they felt sorry for him and that was about the extent of it. He’s been dead for over 30 years.
Then why did Princess Diana name her son Harry after him?
The camera crew sure came in handy on his DUI cases. He was doing reenactments of driving patterns, etc long before VHS captured the arrests. He was the best DUI lawyer I ever saw.
IM READY FOR MY CLOSEUP MR. DeMILLE
Is that Mr. Glukin?
LYNCHWORM after he lost his election by a landslide. One of Moron Ross’ henchmen.
Its urban legend.
Harry was duped into making those mockups.
I JUST WANTED MY SHARE
Rumor had it that Anna the banana got her fair share – of what is the question?
She got more than her share. Ask Johnny and Peter Potato Head and many others. No shortage of flakes to fill that bowl.
Since DeSantis has not applied for any Federal Aid to pay for Alagator Alctaz, how much is this going to cost the taxpayers of our state? The cost per day, per inmate is $700.00.
Its so worth it though,, getting to watch freeloading illegals scream and bitch, demanding “due process” – even though they came in illegally.
This was just a sceme for the top Trump donors to get very big goverment contracts. The top nine donors were the first to be awarded for their supportt. I find it odd that DeSantis didnt secure government funding before allowing this to come to our state, who does that? Now, our taxes will have to take a hit, AGAIN,. Why is it that we have to pay for this place?
We should have reparations from all those who have killed raped stabbed car jacked assaulted
Anyone wonder if this is Scherer herself drawing attention away from herself lol?
today july 4th, let’s remember all the judges who dont follow the constitution
Barbara McCarthy
Yup!
Is Judge Elizabeth Scherer the worst judge Broward ever had? She was the trifecta:
1. Unfair (cruel)
2. Lazy
3. Incredibly stupid
All three of the above …
TUTER WAS JUST FOLLOWING ORDERS
How was I supposed to know how dumb she was ?
Those lips are fake like the rest of her. She’s a Botox Bimbo.
Address this question: why do so many blacks commit crimes?
WHY LIZ BIT THE BIG ONE
Answer that question, dammit.
She definitely wins the BACDL Dimwit Award ! Lol
She’s a Glumpkin winner? Seriously?
Beady eyed little bimbo riding on the taxpayer’s backs. Now Liz licks stamps and prays for redemption.
Liz was just as lazy when she was a SA as she was as a judge. And just as stupid I might add. It’s probably why she was so lazy because she didn’t want people to know just how dumb she was.
I pray every day they’ll forget about me …
Elizabeth Sxcherer was nothing more than a chump in daddy and Tooty’s little game that didn’t end well for any of them despite their attempts to control the narrative on her departure from the bench in disgrace.
Liz’s stupidity and laziness is well known and talked about. But noone talks about how CRUEL and CALLOUS she was.
Liz is one of those judges who can reflect back on her career and know she made a difference — a bad difference. She hurt people, plain and simple.
Hopefully she atones throughout the rest of her life.
She was handed everything on a silver platter. I wonder why she wasn’t thankful instead of being so mean and abusing the system by being so gosh darned absentee and late when she even bothered to be there (in the morning). I mean gee whiz so many people wanted that job and actually deserved it and would’ve been appreciative and worked in service if they had gotten it instead of her.
She was late for the reading of the verdict. Like 45 minutes late, was that to have her makeup done and/or wait for tranquilizers to set in? She looked like the Batman Joker what a display.
She was in over her head from the time she took the bench. It wasn’t all her fault. Tuter should have known better than allow her to try the Cruz case but the lure of celebrity and attention was too intoxicating to resist. Tuter has always been a sham and Liz was too stupid to realize what she was getting into.
LIZ HAS ALWAYS BEEN A BRAINLESS TWIT AND TUTER IS TO BLAME FOR PUTTING IT ON EXHIBIT FOR ALL TO SEE AS A PAYBACK TO DADDY
She was a pawn in somebody else’s game and couldn’t carry the weight . In the end it had its way with her.
Tuter could have reassigned the case to a judge other than now-former Judge Elizabeth Scherer, who was assigned the case randomly and had never presided over or tried a death penalty case.
But he stuck with her.
Asked if he should have made the switch, he said, “Either way you’re going to get criticized. If you give it to somebody who’s, for instance, had experience, but then you look at their record and see well, they had four death penalty cases and three of them were reversed.”
https://www.nbcmiami.com/news/local/top-broward-judge-jack-tuter-reflects-on-tenure-as-he-prepares-to-retire/3552473/
yeah, right
?
JT and Whiney were probably the worst CJ’s in history given the constant JQC turmoil of the judiciary they ineptly were in charge of. If the County Commission had a shred of decency they’d strip both Tuter and Weinstein’s name off the courtroom walls. It’s an affront to anyone that knows the truth. Broward County shouldn’t be installing totems of ineptitude and should rather name courtrooms for people like George Allen and Dr. Sistrunk who were truly courageous purveyors of leadership.
Black crime!!!
GET UP IN THEIR FACES
Always thought she was a spoof considering how she got to the bench thru a rigged JNC process after skating her way thru her tenure in the SA;s Office and then is assigned the Cruz case in a highly questionable way which still bears scrutiny rather than an experienced and knowledgeable judge.
Tuter bears responsibility and some say was part of the farce.
Now she and Tuter are reunited working for Scherer again. Any wonder why ? The co-conspiracy after its failure lands back in the nest if you ask me.
Liz Scherer goes down in a very long list of incompetent Broward judges but stands out as one of the worst for many reasons.
I guess she has attained a certain degree of notoriety, but not in the way she and Tuter intended, and certainly not with their integrity intact.
Defense attorneys: do you like black crime?
Big win for the brothas !
Eli will be remembered for the debacle of the Parkland trial. But she should be remembered for all the other crap she did in her day to day docket. Such as refusing to hold bond hearings when asked, such as launching people who did not deserve it, such as her ineptitude, and above all …how unfair she was to those who came before her.
Thankfully she is off the bench
SHE WOULD NOT PROVIDE BOND HEARINGS BECAUSE SHE WAS GOING TO DENY THEM ANYWAYS
People like her have no moral compass. They lack basic empathy for other human beings. She is one of those people who thinks “tough on crime” is a moral justification to excessively punish people or to deny due process.
Don’t forget how late she was getting on the bench, that’s if she came in at all.
She would show up late. Then finish the docket in 35 minutes. A docket which included 4 motions to reduce bond, 3 motions to compel, 2 motions to vacate capias, and 1 motion to travel along with 20+ calendar calls and VOP statuses.
How? She would just interrupt and deny everything. No due process.
If she didn’t finish fast enough to her liking she would reset everything.
Scherer was nasty and heartless
Why do you all ignore black crime?
Shut up Elizabeth
Is it a coincidence that Jack Tuter ended up at the same firm as Scherer? Did they know each other well before she was on the bench?
He ran for Judge and came in 4th. It was the election with Perry Thurston that Michael Kaplan won in the end and some other person. Then he went to work for Scherer the king of the JNC. Then like a short time later he was appointed to the bench despite the strong message the voting people had sent a couple years before when he came in dead last. Then he latched on to whomever the Chief was after Damoorgian left and was in Admin until Weinstein got him elected successor Chief. This is all my recollection so Google it to make sure.
This link says Tuter got 9%.
https://www.sun-sentinel.com/2002/10/05/two-will-face-off-for-broward-circuit-court-seat/
LAST PLACE LUCY
GOOD ENOUGH FOR BROWARD
I wonder if he brings a bag lunch to his creepy courtroom and eats a sandwich under his painting?
He has a PAINTING!?
There’s a fucking PAINTING of this guy in our courthouse?
WHAT DID HE EVER DO?
SOMEONE EXPLAIN TO ME HOW THE FUCK THIS GUY HAS A PAINTING OF HIMSELF!?!?
it’s a low bar 🙂
Was Babs worse than Scherer though?
No, she worked a full day everyday.
Doesn’t matter, mccarthy was even more unfair, better an unfair lazy judge like scherer than someone who is actively trying to railroad you
The fact that Mccarthy worked everyday made her worse. You had to deal with her incompetence more often
McCarthy didn’t try to capitalize on the misery of Parkland like u know who.
So f’ng gross.
Tuter has always been a bad joke as CJ
Bill: we need new material. Anything but Glopstin.
I’LL DRINK TO THAT
No sir, I am not wearing panties and a bra under my suit
How do you explain the cocaine residue recovered from your buttocks?
Yes, that’s the paper the defendant bludgeoned me with
That’s correct, Mr. Mason. It was a donkey penis.
My client wasn’t the killer. The evidence shows it was Colonel Mustard in the library with the donkey penis.
I thought it was a cannoli
I really think if a poll were conducted on the performance of Elizabeth Scherer as a Broward Judge, the numbers would almost uniformly support the opinion that she is an lazy, incompetent idiot.
Her co-conspirator Tuter would rate right up there with her.
Is there anything going on with the trial against Judge Farmer or are they giving in to him? Does anybody know?
Politics
Someone should make a painting of Jack Tuter and Elizabeth Scherer together LOL
BACK DOOR TOOTY HEADS HOME
THE JQC KNOWS BROWARD WELL
TUTER’S CARNIVAL CIRCUIT
GOOD RIDDANCE TO THE LOSINGEST MANAGER IN BASEBALL
Why doesn’t Bill do blog posts about the bad judges in felony? Bill, noone cares about former judge Bob Diaz or Deborah Carpenter Toye!
Make posts about Coleman, Odom, etc!
Your desire for a post so you can anonymously bash people is just weird.
in fairness to op those people deserve to be bashed
MY MEMORY WILL OUTLAST ME
TACOS ARE MY CREED
Bill: enough already. Put some new stuff on here right now. Not later, now. I am pissed at you.
They never talk about me on here! 😇
She’s a disgrace
Circus freak !
Nice watch.
Did she buy that from Scott Rothstein’s watch business partner. What was the brand and that guys name. Everybody was wearing those watches. Except ol Scotty he had the real stuff from that famous local jeweler. What a mess
The judiciary has not rebounded from that fiasco and continues to fall on itself.
Hello judge my name is. .. judge response I read your motion, motion denied. But I didn’t get to argue my motion. Denied. My nail appointment is 930. Denied have a good day counsel.
I’VE GOT A BRIDGE I WANT TO SELL YOU IN BROOKLYN
ALL BROWARD JUDGES KNEW WHAT WAS REALLY GOING ON AND STILL TOOK CAMPAIGN CONTRIBUTIONS FROM THIS CROOK OF CROOKS
ROTHSTEIN FLED TO MOROCCO
NOT ISRAEL
Which one am I gonna while doing 50 years.
BROWARD JUDGES WENT FOR CHEAP
Hey Scarface ha ya doin’. Get the fuck atta here. Do you who I am. Get the fuck atta here
I don’t think that line works in prison or witness protection? You chose which one. I chose the latter!!!!
I’m wrong he was Goodfella per Bob Norman.
Sure we do, Susan.
I recall the post about your Crazy Eyes, and how you have no understanding of the terms patience or fairness.
SHE’S A MIDNIGHT SIDE SHOW EVEN BY BROWARD JUDICIAL STANDARDS
More like unresolved childhood trauma …
Childhood forest of unforgotten sanity lol
Greetings to every single one of our aquatic tranquility fans!
There’s nothing really like relaxing within a hot spa after a grueling day. For people in search of the absolute tranquility experience, a jacuzzi is truly unparalleled.
Diversity is indeed the herb of lifetime, and we wholeheartedly pride ourselves on offering a diverse array of spas to satisfy every whim.
Superiority, to us, is not just a mere word. It’s our benchmark. Each of our products are subjected to strict testing to ensure they always provide the optimum comfort experience for many years to come.
Our knowledgeable staff are always on hand to assist you in choosing the perfect spa for your requirements and residence.
Have you ever considered having your very own enjoyment retreat? Things are your desires when it pertains to choosing the perfect spa? Let’s talk regarding this!
Be lively and tranquil! Furthermore, I set up my very own recent businesses online business not long ago, you can view it here: https://southwestspas.com/product/655-signature-self-cleaning-hot-tub/ – swim spa Glendale, Arizona
9f8_6f3
Sir, Broward’s judges might be interested in a spa day, Monday to Friday, preferably during business hours.
Ah ha! Mr. Swim Spa from Glendale Arizona, YOU are the reason our judges don’t work!
Hi sir! I am a judge here in Broward. I’m free for a spa day on Monday at 9:00am! Thanks!
All these memes about judges. As bad as they are, its not fair for the judges to get all the attention. How come noone talks about the dirtiest or most unethical prosecutors?
Uh, not so.
every tine Pascal puts her shameful self up for judge, she gets a proper shellacking.
as a person who openly hates pascal Achille, my hearts gets so warmed every time I see someone post about her on here. we need a support group.
Its so easy to see that a total whack job if you’ve ever had any dealings with her
Something is very wrong with her
Bill=0
Trump=10
Need something new this old blog is old a newish girl getting stoked by a black man, should have ended it.
Has anyone taken a recent look at the posts from Lawyer Sean Wydner and his continued lack of awareness regarding his “Fuck Israel” comment on Facebook? He keeps posting comments and is actually complaining he was called out while defending his Anti-Israel comments. He even made these comments while on vacation. What a dick.
He posted “Fuck Israel” and that Israel should be stopped one way or another – on a Jewish person’s FB page – and is whining and complaining that M. Gottlieb responded to his comment ….which I thought was too kind actually. Wydner keeps digging himself into this Anti-Israel corner hole without even an apology as to maybe the choice of words. What kind of lawyer would do that?
Of course, if it was not big deal, why did Wydner delete the post? What kind of judgment does he have when he makes these comments in Broward where he practices law, which has a large jewish population. Shame on him for being not thinking of his law partner before the posted comments.
I love Brian Greenwald’s comment saying it was wrong to bully someone for expressing his views. Apparently it’s OK to post F Israel on a FB comment of a jewish dude, but don’t dare call him out on it when he does. Greenwald’s “but I am also jewish” claim ignores common sense…..Wydner poked the bear by intentionally posting an anti-israel comment on a jewish guy’s FB. Imagine if that was done in other circumstances……
Regardless, that’s my two-cents, which will of course prompt other anti-israel comments on this blog I am sure.
At least Sean Wydner let his true feelings be known…..for better or for worse.
Actually, Sean Wydner did not delete the Anti-Israel comment as I stated in the above post. Perhaps that makes it worse…..it’s proudly displayed.
Whoever this Sean Wydner guy is… he sounds like a hero. Israel is a terrorist state committing genocide. Props to Sean for speaking up even in Broward!
Also props to Brian Greenwald for being jewish and still standing up for freedom of speech.
Props to Grernwald for standing up to Destry and getting him voted out. Personally, I don’t think there’s been a worse Judge ever.
FROM CHIEF JUDGE TO DUMPSTER DIVER
GIVES YOU SOME IDEA ABOUT HIS ADMINISTRATION QUALITIES
Brian was always a standup guy
Destry has always been a complete beaver cleaver
BACDL should have another category of award for anyone that runs against a sitting Judge. Whether they win or lose they make things happen that benefits all of the legal community. It takes a lot of gumption to do it and it should be recognized. Like Grennwald setting the balls in motion for Destry to lose. Like Jahra Mclauren for making Rosenthal lose her shite and getting booted. Or like Judge Bober who beat Dijols. BACDL needs to do more to encourage opposition for all the Judges to stop the baby screaming robe entitlement phenomenon that creeps in and makes a lot of Judges so terrible. They could name it the Al Pacino after the character he played in And Justice For All that was fighting so hard for real justice.
Well, but all Greenbald did is:
Pay a filing fee!
How is that ballsy?! Did he sign his real name to a blog post exposing a judge?
Nah, not buying it.
Best $10,000 I ever spent. You’re welcome!
PEACE ON EARTH
The narrative has changed …
GUESS YOUVE NEVER DATED A JEWISH GIRL
Give me all you got daddy …
CHOCOLATE LOVING JEWISH GIRLS
Girls will be girls. They like it hot.
Were these sluts photographed on the 7th floor of state attorney coffee break room or with that fat public defender. Hopefully he didn’t get them pregnant too!
Felony unit prosecutors demoted for working a second job. But during the work day. Why they can’t call you back for a plea or give discovery on time. Look into Bill.
Rumor confirmed. See who was demoted. Should have been fired. What job was it? Bill you were given new material. Find out.
Beckford ?
Yep. Admin handed down a demotion and then said never mind and decides not to do anything to punish her. Talk about a cover up.
ASA Beckford openly bragging about it in the hallways and court. Bill find the full story
I bet it was prosecutors in Odom. He talks so much that a second job only seems fair.
Bill: are you out of material?
Look into double dipping prosecutors. Working on state hours. Shameful
Rumor has it there is a judicial conference going on. I wonder which Broward judge is gonna make spectacle of themselves. It may be plural with the bunch we got.
Bill: we demand new material. Are you asleep? WT F.
Few people abused their power more than Barbara McCarthy. The sheer evil that she unleashed on those who appeared before her must never be forgotten.
She didn’t just fail to follow the law. She openly spat on it. Her cruelty towards the defendants that appeared before her was unprecedented and unparalleled.
She would deny hearing dates to those who were waiting in jail. She would openly help the prosecution. She would sadistically refuse plea deals. And her sentences reflected her cruelty and psychopathy.
Few people ever wore the black robes who demonstrated a more despicable character.
We are left to wonder if her conscience haunts her at all?
Agreed. One should also add: rotten and malevolent soul. I once saw her put a woman in jail because she capiased after her bailiff refused to allow her in because she was holding her first child. The rot started with her and infected everyone her JA, her clerk, her state attorneys. Just horrible.
EVERYBODY KNOWS THE BROWARD JUDICIARY IS THE BIGGEST CLOWN N SHOW IN THE STATE
St Patricks Day is over. But maybe not being a judge is stressful job requiring a few drinks or more.
Bill and Everyone,
This judge seems pretty bad! There is even a petition to remove her. And the testimonials are very disturbing…
https://www.change.org/p/remove-judge-carbuccia-for-bias-and-overreach-in-the-17th-judicial-circuit-court-florida
lol, I think every judge in family has a website like that, those crazies getting divorced are the worst.
Even if only 10% of the allegations are true, it merits JQC attention and attention from this blog.
Bill the criminal judges aren’t the only bad ones.
Separating children from their fathers is a problem we see too often in family court. Judges favoring mothers, restricting parental rights, and/or disregarding the law is a routine daily occurrence.
She should be held legally accountable if she is not following the law, this is a JQC in the making!
The judicial branch of government continues to demonstrate the following:
1. It is NOT neutral. It favors police, prosecutors, and large corporations.
2. It is by far the weakest branch. It is submissive to the executive branch, including governors, mayors, government agencies, and especially the police. It is afraid to strike down unconstitutional laws written by the legislature. It is afraid to enforce its orders against the other branches.
3. The judiciary is lazy, incompetent, and utterly incapable of delivering due process.
This may seem like an oxymoron but we must both “reel in” the judiciary while simultaneously “empowering” it.
We must reel them in by creating a large and powerful civilian oversight board with the power to evaluate judges who behave unfairly, to evaluate and punish judges who display a lack of neutrality, and to remove judges who lack neutrality! The JQC is not enough. This board would be large and powerful enough to fine, suspend, and remove judges who abuse their power!
Ironically, we must also empower the judiciary with its own sergeants at arms who can effectuate its orders against the executive and legislative branches. For example, if the police or a law enforcement agency ignore the orders of the court, there must be a force of strong men who will arrest them and bring them before the court. A police for the police.
This is the only way.
GOT OUT JUST IN TIME
Judge Kristin Kanner appears to have trouble brewing…
https://www.flgov.com/eog/sites/default/files/executive-orders/2025/EO%2025-133.pdf
Expound!
??.
I clicked: says Kristin Kanner being prosecuted. Pryor had case reassigned for another SAO to prosecute.
Doesnt say what she did.
She’s as dumb as a stump so it could have been anything.
They’re just in the providing coverage stage now, It’ll bubble to the top sooner than later.
MY MIRROR IS MY BIGGEST CRITIC
Michael Jackson Man in the Mirror
Sums it up.
Well he’s been gone some time and the new Admin still hasn’t got paper towels in the courthouse tower bathrooms. So much for change. If I want to eat a melted chocolate bar or a ripe mango out of the husk on lunch break I still have to dry my face after washing up with toilet paper which gets stuck in my eyeliner and I look dumb in court. It’s not much to ask for paper towels.
Toilet paper stuck in your eyeliner looks better than the eye makeup ol Lizzy wore at the Cruz reading of the 17 verdicts.
So don’t be so demanding.
Use a napkin if you have $2 to spare for that square.
The place is a total s hole
I’m back to the mole hole. Plans for Liz didn’t go as planned.
WHO NEEDS TOILET PAPER ?
BROWARD JUDGES NEED A RAISE
Paper towels are a human right.